Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Archive > Other Views
The Muslim Brotherhood shows its true colors
The Muslim Brotherhood shows its true colors
The group?s latest thinking reveals a troubling agenda.
The draft is just that – a draft still open to adjustment, reflecting ongoing debate within the Brotherhood itself about its stances before it publishes the final version of the platform. Still, the preliminary program that it outlines doesn’t herald the democratic values the Brotherhood has claimed to hold in previous public statements and addresses. Instead, it calls for the adoption of a "Civic Islamic State."
Thursday, October 11,2007 19:15
by Mohamed Elmenshawy Christian Science Monitor

If Iran"s Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini were alive today, he would celebrate the expansion of his Islamist vision. As evidenced by the latest version of the Muslim Brotherhood"s recently released political party platform, the late Iranian leader"s dream of spreading the ideology of Islamic revolution is gaining ground in Egypt, the largest Sunni Arab country.

The draft is just that – a draft still open to adjustment, reflecting ongoing debate within the Brotherhood itself about its stances before it publishes the final version of the platform. Still, the preliminary program that it outlines doesn"t herald the democratic values the Brotherhood has claimed to hold in previous public statements and addresses. Instead, it calls for the adoption of a "Civic Islamic State."

Perhaps the most alarming feature of the draft platform is the call to create a Majlis Ulama, or Council of Islamic Scholars, that could end up being elected by Islamic clerics, not through free and fair elections. Reminiscent of Iran"s Guardian Council, this undemocratically selected body could have the power vested by the state to veto any and all legislation passed by the Egyptian parliament and approved by the president that is not compatible with Islamic sharia law.

The Muslim Brotherhood, established in 1928 by Hassan al-Banna, has been outlawed by the Egyptian government since 1954. Today, it packages itself as a moderate organization, and its members hold 88 seats (about a fifth) in the Egyptian parliament as independents. Many Egyptians have long sympathized with the Muslim Brotherhood in its struggle against an increasingly authoritarian regime. It was hard not to feel for the banned organization when its members faced the harsh treatment of Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak"s military tribunals.

Still, having gone since 1928 without releasing any official party platform, the Muslim Brotherhood has escaped an honest and critical review – until now. In publishing this draft, it missed a golden opportunity to prove its pro-democratic stance.

The Muslim Brotherhood should have looked to Turkey as a model for how to integrate Islam into a secular system. The Turkish parliament"s recent election of the Justice and Development Party candidate Abdullah Gul to the presidency produced a proudly Muslim president committed to guarding Turkey as a secular state. In stark contrast to President Gul, Mohamed Habib, the Muslim Brotherhood"s second-in-command said in an interview in August, "Islam is the state religion. No secular citizen is allowed to publicize his secularism, and no laws against the sharia."

The Brotherhood"s consistent call for a purely Islamic state can only mean the marginalization of secular opposition voices.

Also alarming is that the draft document would discriminate on the grounds of gender and religion by denying women and members of Egypt"s Christian Coptic community the right to run for presidential office.

The rise to power of a Muslim Brotherhood based on this new party platform could spell disaster for Egypt"s already tenuous relations with Israel. In the same interview, Mr. Habib assured his followers that the Brotherhood would not recognize the "Zionist entity" or "unjust" international treaties, in reference to the peace treaty signed with Israel in 1979.

Many people used to believe that the Muslim Brotherhood was simply a political movement using religion to gain support and present itself in contrast to the ruling National Democratic Party, but now it appears that the inverse is true. The Muslim Brotherhood is a religious movement using politics to spread its values and beliefs.

In the wake of 9/11, many analysts have called on the American administration and policymakers to engage with so-called moderate Islamists in the Arab world. While engagement is necessary, and greater diplomatic efforts should be encouraged, the Brotherhood"s dangerous political platform should be questioned. Before opening a dialogue with any group – even one that has renounced violence, as the Brotherhood has – there needs to be an examination as to whether a political organization that categorically denies equality on the basis of religion and gender can be lauded as moderate, and whether engagement can lead to positive political reform and democratization.

Egypt is in desperate need of new political blood. With the dictatorial nature of Mr. Mubarak"s 26-year rule and the recent sentencing of several editors in chief, the Egyptian people want a viable alternative.

But the Muslim Brotherhood"s new platform dispels the hope that it could be the lifeline Egypt needs to start becoming a true liberal democracy.

The Egyptian people, lacking a vibrant and diverse political arena, are left to choose between the devil they know and the devil they are now beginning to know.

Mohamed Elmenshawy is editor in chief of Taqrir Washington and Arab Insight, a project of the World Security Institute in Washington, D.C.

Related Topics:


Posted in Other Views , MB in International press  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Habib Heads Committee to Revise Brotherhood Platform
New MB political platform bans Christians, women from presidency, sets up Islamic clerical power
MB in Party Program...Wrong Doers or Wronged?
Brotherhood Party; Future Scenarios
Experts received MB program: call for religious state, Iranian-style
Islamic Party Confident in Morocco
Islamic party courts election victory in moderate Morocco
Success of Turkey’s AK Party must not dilute worries over Arab Islamists
Our country of Justice and Law
Islamists under fire draft first political programme
Why Has MB’s Party Program Been Delayed?
Habib: MB Program Still Under Preparation, Review
Is the Muslim Brotherhood part of Egypt’s democratic future?
The Brotherhood Is in favour of a new Coptic Party
the Brotherhood Studies the Formation of a Conservative Party
El-Arian: the Brotherhood considers the founding of a “conservative” party
EGYPT: Social programmes bolster appeal of Muslim Brotherhood
Dr. Habib explains the Muslim Brotherhood’s’Political Program
Today, Dr. Abdel-Moneim Abu el-Fotouh at a TV program on the satellite Dream Ch2
Egypt: MB Platform For Labor Union Elections
Muslim Brotherhood to pursue legal political party status
Party Politics
El-Erian: MB Will Not Unilaterally Declare Its Political Party
Ibrahim Monir:MB Seeks Civil, not Religious, Party
Muslim Brotherhood to Form New Political Party
MB Bloc: Muslim Brotherhood Party for All Egyptians
Views of Intellectuals, Politicians Over Muslim Brotherhood Party Program
Zakaria: Inside the Paranoia Over Islamic Party
Habib: Democratic Front Party Adds More To Political Life
Mauritania’s MB Seeks Civil Political Party
MB Will Soon Announce Its Political Party Program
The Islamists’ Party in Egypt…No Hope
FEATURE: The Muslim Brotherhood: past struggle, future challenges
El-Zayat’s party is unrelated to Brotherhood, says MB deputy
Future challenges for Brotherhood
AK Party’s democratic success sets model for Middle East
The Electoral Programme of the Muslim Brotherhood for Shura Council in 2007
Future of Muslim Brotherhood
The Muslim Brotherhood’s Program
The Muslim Brotherhood And Political Party
A study on the Future of the MB: Five Potential Scenarios
Mursi: Brotherhood Ready To Establish Civil Political Party