Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Human Rights
Mr Hosni Musharraf
Mr Hosni Musharraf
Politically, is Pakistan going the Egypt way?
If the ban on a twice-elected prime minister running for a third term is not lifted, there will be no real choice for Pakistanis because then Musharraf would be able to appoint anyone he likes as prime minister.
Wednesday, December 12,2007 18:19
by Husain Haqqani, Indianexpress IC PUb

 Musharraf’s language and demeanour are the same as that of Egypt’s ruler Hosni Mubarak at the time of the 1987 elections for the Egyptian parliament. Twenty years later, Mubarak is still in power and the Egyptian people still have no real choice between leaders.

Egypt is a nation of a thousand NGOs and several political parties but there is no serious political challenge to Mubarak’s authority. Mubarak marginalised the real opposition, allowed western funded NGOs to work within pre-defined spheres, and has regularly held elections without allowing alternation in power.

Musharraf’s guns are trained on Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif for a reason. Having served as prime ministers, the two are visible reminders that Pakistan can be ruled by someone other than Musharraf. Once they are out of the way, Musharraf can follow Mubarak in holding election after election, changing rules and judges as often as he likes, and control the country with the help of the security services and large amounts of US aid.

Incidentally, Mubarak (who started out as an air force general) has been a civilian and out of uniform for the last 25 years but that has not eased the grip of the military and the intelligence services on Egypt’s polity. Musharraf’s decision to continue to live in ‘army house’ after ostensibly handing over command to General Ashfaq Kayani reflects his desire to be Pakistan’s Mubarak.

The holding of free and fair elections is not a technical issue; it is a matter of intent. A ruler or government that has no intention of sharing or transferring power is unlikely to hold free and fair elections.

Most of the fix for the coming elections is already in — manipulated voters’ lists, gerrymandering, intimidation of opposition candidates and arm-twisting of local influentials to support the king’s party. The rigging will be selective on election day, outside of the view of foreigners and the media as far as possible.

The primary purpose of the regime would be to influence the outcome both in terms of who gets elected and how many seats each party gets. Thus, the opposition might get a significant number of seats but individuals with an independent mind could be made to lose.

After the elections, a second round of manipulation will take place to create factions within each party and to manage a pliant coalition. This would be similar to what happened in 2002. A coalition cobbled together in the same manner as 2002 after a fraudulent election euphemistically described as ‘flawed but acceptable’ by the US government will not advance democracy in Pakistan.

If the ban on a twice-elected prime minister running for a third term is not lifted, there will be no real choice for Pakistanis because then Musharraf would be able to appoint anyone he likes as prime minister.

Musharraf’s desire to exclude Bhutto and Sharif and thereby pave the way for choosing a prime minister himself is another sign that he is following the Hosni Mubarak role model. But while Musharraf may want to emulate the Egyptian model, Pakistani civilians will not roll over and play dead. Prolonged unrest might follow a rigged poll in Pakistan.

By failing to understand the differences between the political history and aspirations of Egypt and Pakistan, Musharraf might be risking considerable and prolonged unrest in trying to emulate Mubarak.

The writer is director of Boston University’s Center for International Relations [email protected]

Posted in Human Rights , MB in International press  
Related Articles
Mubarak Curbs Dissent, Paves Way for Next President (Update1)
Roger Cohen: Viva Mubarak, Fuera Chavez!
Mubarak rejects foreign pressure
Mubarak’s Son Denies Succession Move
Musharraf shows dictators how it’s done
Egypt ruling party keeps Mubarak
US-Egyptian relations post-Mubarak: Plus ca change...
Egypt’s Mubarak too weak to travel; son Gamal being groomed
Egypt’s media defy Mubarak at their peril
Hisham Qasim to Reuters: No Progress As Long As Mubarak Is in Power. No Reformists in NDP
Qadi Hussein: Pakistani People Refuse Musharraf & His Policies
Jailed Brotherhood leaders accuse Mubarak’s regime of politicizing the army
With tough moves, Egypt moves to ensure stability whenever post-Mubarak era dawns
Egyptian Opposition Paper Editor Stands Trial for Article on Mubarak’s Failing Health
With tough moves, Egypt moves to ensure stability whenever post-Mubarak era dawns
Contrary to Mubarak’s Rhetoric , Egypt Remains Mired in Authoritarianism
Mubarak’s crackdown on labor activists continues…
Egyptian editors jailed for defaming Mubarak
Pak Islamic Group: We Will Take to Streets If Musharraf Reelected
Egypt Strives to Quell Mubarak Rumors
Egyptian journalist probed over Mubarak health rumours - Feature
Mubarak blames Muslim Brotherhood for spreading rumors he is dead
Egyptian Journalist Questioned by State Security Over Mubarak Health Reports
Rumors of Mubarak’s death
Egypt’s Mubarak is in good health, first lady says
Egypt Under Mubarak: Years of the Disappeared
Mubarak’s dangerous game
Mubarak’s Son to Be NDP Leader
Rice warns Mubarak world will watch elections in Egypt
The West Should Push Mubarak on Reform
Letter to President Mubarak on Muslim Brotherhood Arrests
Egypt Opposition Unites Against Mubarak
Mubarak: Polls to boost legislative reform
Mubarak to Al Ahram: Egypt’s national unity is a red line
Mubarak says turnout will be key to elections
Mubarak`s son stands out in Egypt campaign
Mubarak’s party takes a cue from opposition
Mubarak’s re-election lacks fairness, says Judges Club
Mubarak Rival Loses Parliamentary Seat
Islamists take on Mubarak’s party in Egypt vote
Mubarak’s party ousts rival leader in Egypt vote By Tom Perry
Mubaraks stand on back foot
Mubarak’s Political Advisor , Al Baz: We are not Worried About The Muslim Brotherhood’s Rise
Mubarak Outdoes Himself, Election Fraud Backfires
Egypt to hold election run-offs, Mubarak’s dilemma
Group of Democratic Development calls Mubarak to release one of its volunteers
Mubarak sends message to Egypt’s Islamists
Saving Egypt from Mubarak
How Mubarak hijacked democracy
Gamal Mubarak: No Deals between the MB and NDP
Mubarak’s Son Attacks Brotherhood
Mr. Mubarak’s Rollback
Judges Turn to President Mubarak to Intervene
Mubarak Reneging on Promises of Democratic Reform
Egypt: Mubarak Regime Cracks Down on Opposition
Egyptian Islamists hamstrung by Mubarak’s dominance
MB Denies Mediation With Gamal Mubarak & Rejects Power Succession
Mubarak’s Remarks… a Timely Surprise
Mubarak’s reform promises backslide
As Mubarak era enters twilight, spotlight falls on son
Mubarak faces the end of his status quo
Mubarak vs. a Dissenting Judiciary
Gamal Mubarak Denies Egypt Reneging on Reform
Mubarak’s Son Met Secretly With Bush and Cheney
CKUT Radio: Egypt - Mubarak & Political Dissent.
VIEW: The Domestic Wars of Hosni Mubarak
Mubarak seems to be running scared from democracy
Hosni Mubarak, Elections or no, he’s still Pharaoh.
Egypt: The Gamal Mubarak Paradox
Mubarak Intervenes To Soften Press Law
Egypt’s Mubarak sees no need for vice president
Bush Administration concerned with the issue of Mubarak absence
Mubarak Launches Limited Cabinet Reshuffle
Mubarak Moving to Close Political Opening Created for Election
NFC Calls On Mubarak to Withdraw From Camp David Treaty
’’Mubarak Pressured by Domestic Dissent and Regional Challenges’’
Egyptians Call on Mubarak to Sever Relations with Vatican
Mubarak’s Son Proposes Nuclear Program
Gamal Mubarak Speaks of Egypt’s Right To Nuclear Energy
Mubarak’s Speech Does Not Hold Together, Professor Says
Mubarak: Egypt’s new ’pharaoh’ and great survivor
Mubarak’s quarter of a century
’Egyptians won’t stop Mubarak dynasty’
Mubarak hopes to stay on for life
Hala Mustafa: My Clash with Security Apparatus, not Gamal Mubarak
Aboul-Fotouh Urges President Mubarak to Release Al-Erian
Egyptian Opposition Rejects Mubarak’s Amendments
MB Response To President Mubarak Accusations
122 MPs Rejected Mubarak’s Constitutional Amendments
After Mubarak
Mubarak Steps Up Fight on Muslim Brotherhood
Mubarak responds to Brotherhood ’threat’
Mubarak Sends MB Leaders To Military Tribunal!
Mubarak and Democracy
Abdul Qoddous Equates Mubarak’s Regime With IOF
Mubarak’s spring chill
Heikal on Gamal Mubarak
Ibrahim Darwish: Mubarak Jr. Is Coming
President Mubarak urged to keep promise he made three years ago
Egypt: Strike wave shakes Mubarak regime
Mubarak Making Way For Terrorism
Photos: Mubarak’s Gestapo brutalize March 2003 anti-war protestors
45 Jordanian MPs Call On Mubarak To Release MB Detainees
Group Blasts Mubarak’s Anti-Terror Bill
Brotherhood, Independent MPs Boycott House Sessions Over Mubarak’s Amendments
MB Responds to Mubarak’s Warn of Mixing Religion, Politics
Gamal Mubarak Faints During NDP General Secretariat Meeting
HRW to Mubarak’s regime: Investigate police torture, rape of blogger Sharqawi
Pharaoh’s Triangulation;America Should Be Wise to Mubarak’s Game
Egyptians in Vienna Protest Mubarak’s Constitutional Amendments
Egyptians In Vienna Protest At Mubarak’s Constitutional Amendments
For Egypt’s Mubarak, how much power is enough?
3000 protest Mubarak’s amendments in Alexandria
US anti-Mubarak protests
Star Academy and Hosny Mubarak
Bush should push Musharraf on elections this year in Pakistan
Anti-torture activists: Mubarak’s police knows no limit
US gives green light for Mubarak
Mubarak Jr.’s Call For Dialogue Met With Skepticism
Hosni Mubarak’s crackdown in Egypt fails to dampen strike wave
Egyptian Prisoners in Israel - Open Letter to President Mubarak
Al Shater’s Defence: Ball Now In Mubarak’s Court
Robert Springborg: Mubarak’s Rule
Mubarak’s Top Advisor: MB Has Good Agenda
Mubarak: Hamas will never sign a peace agreement with Israel
London protestors denounce Mubarak’s military tribunals
Brother Gamal Mubarak
President Mubarak, "May God offer him prayers and salutations"
Blogging Against Mubarak
BBC Newsnight: Mubarak’s Police State
Egypt: Human Rights Watch Asks Mubarak to Investigate Police Brutality
Mubarak’s Achievements: 20% of Egyptians Under Poverty Line
Gamal Mubarak’s Call For Dialogue Met With Skepticism
Monday: London Anti-Mubarak Demo
Demonstrations against Mubarak’s military tribunals in London and Cairo
CAIRO, Sept 7 (Reuters) - President Hosni Mubarak is widely expected to win Egypt’s first multi-cand
Mubarak set to win Egypt poll, critics cry foul
Rally held against Mubarak fifth term
Islamists urge Egyptians to vote out Mubarak
Poor Turnout Undermines Mubarak’s Legitimacy: Experts
Gamal Mubarak launches ruling party’s Battle of Cairo
Mubarak asks Muslim scholars to teach tolerance
Protest follows Mubarak ceremony
Mubarak Plans to Get His Son, Gamal, Appointed President
Mubarak Promises Egypt That Elections Will Be Fair
Gamal Mubarak: Egypt’s Next President?
Democratic Deficits in Egypt, The Domestic Wars of Hosni Mubarak
Mubarak’s Regime Rejects Amnesty International Report
Sudanese MPs Call on Mubarak to Release Opposition Leaders
Abd Al-Rahman Seoudi Honored by Mubarak, Detained by Al Adli
Hosni Mubarak’s regime won’t delete Egypt’s bloggers