Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Prisoners of Conscience
Military Tribunals & International HR Watchdogs
Military Tribunals & International HR Watchdogs
On Feb. 6th, 40 Muslim Brotherhood leaders, headed by MB 3rd-in-command Eng. Khairat El-Shater and MB Executive Bureau Member Dr. Muhammad Ali Bishr, who were pending under a high state security case, have been referred to military justice pursuant to a presidential decree.
Thursday, December 13,2007 10:07
by Nadine Abdullah IkhwanWeb

On Feb. 6th, 40 Muslim Brotherhood leaders, headed by MB 3rd-in-command Eng. Khairat El-Shater and MB Executive Bureau Member Dr. Muhammad Ali Bishr, who were pending under a high state security case, have been referred to military justice pursuant to a presidential decree.

Up to this day, 16 military trial sessions held for the MB leaders, mostly monitored by international watchdogs and representatives of high-profile HR bodies that were denied access into the courtroom at all.

The second trial session was highly attended by human rights activists and representatives such as Haitham Manna’, spokesman of the Arab Human Rights Commission, Dr. Anis Qassim & Hassibah Sahrawi, representatives of Amnesty International, Eligah Zoran, a Human Rights Watch consultant and chairman of the Turkish Bar Association & independent HR and legal activists as Dr. Faisal Kutty from Canada. After being denied access, the human rights group stated that the way the Egyptian Authorities treat human rights activists and representatives “would have serious repercussions.” Notably, this was the first international rights group to come for attending the military tribunal and barred from the courtroom.

In his statement to www.ikhwanweb.com , the Muslim Brotherhood English Website, Dr. Kutty comments on the fairness and impartiality of such military tribunals saying, “The government is basically running that tribunal. I don’t think this would be really satisfying because eventually if you have the executive which is the president appointing the military tribunals and taking such decision, how would that be independent or impartial?! Certainly there is no independence, and there is no impartiality.”

The third session observed by Ex U.S. Attorney General Ramsey Clark, former Queen’s Counsel and British MP Ivan Lawrence, UK Award-winning journalist & HR activist Yvonne Ridley, CEO of Justice International Dr. Mohie-Eddine and Amnesty International representative Sameeh Kharais, while a UK Attorney and international legal activist Ali Azhar denied entrance to Egypt by the security apparatus without reason.

In the internationally-covered press conference, Clark affirmed "It is pitiful to see a great people like the Egyptian people with a government so afraid, so afraid of its own position in power that it continuously persecutes the Muslim Brotherhood. It is highly political, obviously" he said. Ridley described the Brotherhood’s trial as "unprecedented" and a "miscarriage of justice" adding that the hearing "brought shame on the Egyptian government."

On August 5th, Dr. Violette Daguerre, General Coordinator of the Paris-based Arab Human Rights Committee, who came to observe the fourth session along with the Amnesty’s Sameeh Kharais, commented on those trials saying: “These military tribunals are just a false unreal political tribunal, and it has nothing to do with conventional tribunals. It is just a farce and a comical play.” On his part, Sameeh Kharais, described those trials as “politically-motivated travestying of justice” adding "What happened defames the trial and the Egyptian government’s interests because Amnesty’s presence could have added legitimacy to the procedure."

UNHRC Envoy Ammar Al-Qirbi, who attended the 5th, 6th, 9th and 10th session and, by the way, denied access affirmed that those military tribunals against Muslim Brotherhood are “taxes the group pays for its political success.”

After being barred from the 5th and the 6th sessions alike, Mr. Mahdi Bray, CEO of the US-based MAS Freedom Foundation and famous human rights activist, stated in the press conference saying "whether in Egypt or the USA, whether the dissidents are Islamist or secular, the use of military tribunals to persecute and imprison lawful dissidents and activists constitutes a grave violation of international law that we will continue to challenge."

Past president of the American National Lawyers Guild Bruce Nestor announced, before a press conference for assessing the situation after being banned from the courtroom that the Egyptian regime went into extremes along with the US government in violating basic human rights, calling upon the two to abide by the HR treaties and pacts they signed. “The military tribunal insists on slapping the defendants with unfair verdict” he said.

As happened with his comrades Violette and Ammar, Mr. Abdul-Rahim Khammaza, who serves as a secretary-General of the Syrian Human Rights Commission and a member of the Arab Human Rights Commission, denied access to the court in its 12th session. In his statement, Ghammaza stressed on the political impetus behind these trials saying: “those military tribunals are outlawed while used as a tool for political liquidation”

After denying him access to the 15th military tribunal session, Dr. Khurrum B. Wahid, a well-known American legal activist, has stated that preventing him from getting in clearly proves that “the court case is totally political!” adding “I’m not here for defending Muslim Brotherhood. I came here for monitoring fairness, but, unfortunately, I was prevented from doing so.”

The same applied to Mrs Rosalie P. Jeter, who accompanied Dr. Khurrum to the court. Rosalie, a civil society activist and the Founder and Executive Director of the Muslim Women’s Institute for Research and Development (MWIRD), stated “Preventing us from attending today’s session proves the illegality of such session.” And wondered "What does the Egyptian government hide inside the court?! Preventing us from attending the sessions is a clear proof that the government is hiding something wrong."



Note-worthy, this is regarded the seventh military trial against MB members under Mubarak regime. That kind of justice is well known for quick trials and arbitrary sentences, heedless to the internationally-defined criteria for fair trials.


Posted in Prisoners of Conscience , Military Tribunal , Human Rights  
Related Articles
They said about military trials
Military Tribunals & International HR Watchdogs
Military Tribunals & Status of Human Rights In Egypt
Children for Freedom
MB Detainees families suffer
Muslim Brotherhood leader decries Egypt military trial
Military trial of Brotherhood members a ’farce,’ group leader says
Last Chapter - Controversial Military Tribunal against MB Leaders in Last Stage
MB Leaders Military Trial to Tuesday, Dec, 11th
Al Shater’s Military Trial Adjourned till Thursday
Al Shater’s Military Trial Adjourned till Thursday
Ramsey Clark in Cairo to Monitor MB Military Trial
Military Trial of MB Leaders Resumes Today
ACHR Delegate Denied Access to MB Military Trial
AIC to Shed Light on MB Military Tribunal
Top Rights Activist in Cairo Monday to Monitor MB Military Trial
MB Military Trial Adjourned to Tuesday
MB Military Tribunal Adjourns Session till Wednesday, Oct, 10th
MB Military Trial Adjourned To Tuesday
18th Session of MB Military Trial on Wednesday
Gov’t Expert Witness Rejects Money Laundry Charges In MB Military Trial
Expert Committee Chief Gives 6 Surprises in Monday MB Military Trial
MB Military Tribunal Adjourned till Oct, 3rd, Daguerre Denied Access
Daguerre Back to Cairo today to Monitor MB Military Tribunal
Int’l Observers Denied Access to MB Trial, Al Shater’s Health Deteriorates
Military Tribunal Adjourns Session to Oct.1st
MB Military Trial Adjourned till next Wednesday Sep, 26th
Khurrum and Rosalie Barred from Monitoring MB Military Tribunal
Al-shater military tribunal, next Sat
Qurabi on Syrian Human Rights Situation, Military Tribunal of Egypt’s MB
Al Shater’s Military Trial Adjourned to next Sunday
Egyptian Authorities Deny Ammar Qurabi Access to MB 10th Military Session
Qurabi: Human Rights Groups Should Move to Monitor MB Military Court
Ammar Qurabi to Thursday’s Al-Shater 10th Military Session
MB Leader Standing Military Trial Admitted to ICU
Int’l Observers Denied Access to MB Military Session for 9th Time in a row
Qurabi in Egypt to Monitor Sunday’s MB Military Trial
Egyptian Security Denies Military Court Detainee Treatment
Grave Violations in Financial Report of Al-Shater’s Military Case
Al Shater’s Military Trial Adjourned Until next Sunday
Military Tribunal Resumes Amid Worries about Al Shater’s Health
Brotherhood military trial continues despite El Shater health concerns
Al-Shater’s Military Court Adjourned till next Wednesday
Al Shater’s Military Trial Adjourned Until next Tuesday
Al-Shater’s Military Trial Adjourned till Next Tuesday
UNHRC & MAS Freedom Barred from Monitoring Military Tribunals
Rights Activists Will Attend Next Military Tribunal Though Repeatedly Denied Access
ACHR Denounces Preventing Observers From Attending MB Military Tribunals
International observers and attorneys denied access to fourth military trial
Violette Daguerre: MB Military Tribunals are False& Unreal Political Tribunals
ACHR Chief to Attend Sunday’s MB Military Tribunal
Amnesty wants observers at Egypt Islamists’ trial
Independent observers needed in Egyptian military court
The National Front gather 5000 Observers
The national coalition is preparing five thousand observers
EOHR observers were deprived from watching out counting votes processes
Popular Tribunal To Try Police Officers Accused of Torture
Demand an Immediate International Criminal Tribunal for Israel to Stop Global War
Military Tribunals for MB activists!!
Mubarak Sends MB Leaders To Military Tribunal!
Military trial for Khayrat el Shater, Yusuf Nada, 40 MB Members
Rights Organizations Condemn Military Tribunals For MB Members
Profiles of MB Members Refered to Military Tribunals, Ayman Abdul Ghani and Others
Joint Statement We Condemn Egyptian Regime’s Attack Against Opposition, Reject Military Tribunals
Egyptians in Texas Protest Military Tribunals For MB Members
Egyptian Doctors Protest Referring 22 Union Members To Military Trials
Administrative Court Hears MB Appeal Against Military Trials On Tuesday
Rights Groups Urge MB Boycott Military Tribunal
Aljazeera.net Surfers Reject Transferring MB Leaders To Military Tribunal
Egypt’s Highest Court Cancels Military Trials For MB Detainees
Administrative Court acquits MB leaders; argues military tribunals are ‘unconstitutional’
Court Upholds Gov’t Appeal Against Suspending MB Military Trials
London protestors denounce Mubarak’s military tribunals
Kifaya: No To Trying Civilians Before Military Tribunal
Govt Prevents Rights Groups From Observing MB Military Trial
Brotherhood Military Trial Adjourned to July 15th
AOHR’s Deputy Chief: MB Military Tribunal Bone-Breaking Between Regime, Justice
Egypt military trial of top Muslim Brotherhood members resumes
Egypt: Flawed Military Trials for Brotherhood Leaders
Families of MB Detainees Protest Military Trials To Parliament
Military Tribunal Detainee Holds Cardiac Surgery
General Attorney Clark to Arrive Cairo for Military Tribunals
BBC Surfers Reject Military Tribunal Against MB Leaders
Ramsey Clark: Brotherhood tribunal is an ‘attack on Islam’
MB Military Trial Adjourned to August 5th
Demonstrations against Mubarak’s military tribunals in London and Cairo
Petition: No to Govt’s Assault on Opposition; No to Military Tribunals
200 University Professor Launch Campaign to Reject Military Tribunals
Ruling On MB’s Appeal Against Military Court Tomorrow
Ikhwanweb’s Coverage of the April 26th MB Military Trial Session
Military tribunal of detained MB members opens quietly
Military Trial For MB Leaders Adjourned Till June 3rd
Military Trials For MB Leaders To Begin Tomorrow April 26
Statement by MB Leaders Referred to Military Tribunal
Egypt: Appeal Against Referral to Military Tribunal Adjourned