Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Human Rights
Anatomy of a State Security Case
Anatomy of a State Security Case
The Victorious Sect Arrests
On April 19, 2006, Egyptian and international media reported that authorities had just arrested members of an extremist armed group in Cairo that was alleged to have been plotting terrorist attacks. Among the headlines were “Egypt foils terror bombing attempt” and “Egypt says terror group broken up.”1 The Egyptian Interior Ministry had announced that day that State Security Investigations (SSI),2 Egypt’s domestic intelligence agency, had arrested 22 suspects who they alleged had been p
Wednesday, December 19,2007 06:24
Human Rights Watch

On April 19, 2006, Egyptian and international media reported that authorities had just arrested members of an extremist armed group in Cairo that was alleged to have been plotting terrorist attacks. Among the headlines were “Egypt foils terror bombing attempt” and “Egypt says terror group broken up.”1 The Egyptian Interior Ministry had announced that day that State Security Investigations (SSI),2 Egypt’s domestic intelligence agency, had arrested 22 suspects who they alleged had been plotting to bomb civilian targets in and around Cairo, including gas pipelines and tourist sites, and to kill Muslim and Christian religious figures. The Interior Ministry said the group was called al-Taifa al-Mansura, “The Victorious Sect.”

Five days later, on April 24, a string of bombings in Dahab, in the Sinai Peninsula, killed 18 people—the first bombing attack in Egypt since 2005 and the only such attack in 2006. (At this writing, there had been no major bombing attacks in Egypt since the Dahab attack.) Unsurprisingly, some journalists connected the April 19 announcement with the subsequent Dahab bombings, suggesting that the group arrested might be connected to the bombings.3 Some observers also offered deeper analyses of the Victorious Sect arrests based on information provided in the interior ministry statement, suggesting that new strains of “Salafi Jihadism” were on the rise in Egypt and that the threat of terrorism in Egypt was growing.4

The facts about the arrests, however, tell another story.

In June and July 2007, Human Rights Watch investigated the cases of the 22 men referred to as the Victorious Sect. We investigated these cases because of their high profile, caused by the Interior Ministry’s public announcement of the arrests, and because many Egyptian attorneys and civil society leaders suggested that the Interior Ministry’s allegations against the men were untrue.

Human Rights Watch was unable to interview in depth any of the 22 alleged members of the Victorious Sect. The majority of the men were still in custody at the time of our investigation, and most of the 12 who are known to have been released since 2006 are either unavailable for interviewing or have declined to speak to us for fear of endangering themselves or their co-defendants. However, Human Rights Watch did interview other former prisoners who had been held for considerable periods with the 22 detainees, and obtained an account of the detainees’ experience from one of the released detainees. We also interviewed the attorneys for the 22 men, who saw them during legal proceedings, and several family members who visited the men, as well as neighbors, activists, and observers familiar with their cases, and numerous other attorneys who represent SSI detainees. (Notably, several of the men’s family members declined to talk to us because they feared that doing so would make it less likely the men would be released.) Lastly, we attempted without success to meet with officials from the Interior Ministry and Foreign Ministry to discuss the cases; letters requesting information from the Interior Ministry received no reply (see appendix).

Our investigation gives reason to be deeply skeptical about the allegations made against the 22 men. Beyond coerced confessions, there appears to be no compelling evidence to support the government’s dramatic claims. Indeed, it appears that SSI may have fabricated the allegations made against at least some and possibly all of them. The very name given to the group—“Victorious Sect”—may have been invented by SSI officers. Moreover, whether or not the original arrests were justified, it is clear that there are currently no legal grounds for the continued detention of the 10 men of the 22 who are believed to remain in custody. The State Security prosecution office has declined to refer any of the cases to court and in 2006 issued orders that all of the men should be released.

The underlying facts of these cases are also disturbing. To begin with, the 22 men were not arrested in late April 2006, when their detention was announced. Rather, they were detained weeks earlier, in February and March 2006, and held incommunicado in various SSI facilities around Cairo, including Lazoghli, SSI headquarters; the Gaber Ibn Hayan SSI facility in Giza; and the Nasr City SSI facility—none of which are legally authorized places of detention. Some of the men had been detained for over two months before the April announcement.

Attorneys and families believe that the 22 men may have been targeted for arrest because they were more devout Muslims than other mainstream Egyptian youth, and because authorities thought they could take signs of their religiousness—for instance, that some of them had organized theological discussion groups—and transform these signs into proof of more suspicious activity.

Former detainees held with the 22 men, as well as their attorneys and family members, have provided information indicating that most or possibly all of the 22 men were tortured by SSI officials during the weeks they were held in custody before the April 19 announcement. A former detainee who heard a number of the men being interrogated at a SSI facility in Giza described the scene:

What I heard was not just torture; it was beyond imagination. What I heard, it was so unbelievable, even I came to believe that maybe they were involved in something. I started wondering: for them to be tortured like that they must have been involved in some plot. You cannot imagine how harsh it was to hear that, the screaming, how harshly they were tortured . . . . I heard some of them screaming when they were being electrocuted. I could hear the electricity too, the “zizzzt, zizzzt.”

Another former detainee, held with the group in prison, said that “they told us a lot about the torture they suffered” in the Giza facility. In particular:

First, they said they were stripped naked, of course, and for a while they were held out in the hallway, completely naked. Second, electricity, of course, that’s a must, it almost goes without saying. But not just electricity: they said that the officers targeted their most sensitive areas, the genitals. Third, they said they were handcuffed, behind, and then hung up on the top of an open door . . . . Some of those guys told me later that they could smell their own skin burning [during the electroshock torture]; they said it was disgusting.

In addition, in November 2007 Human Rights Watch received information from one of the Victorious Sect detainees who was released in 2007. The detainee claimed that he and other detainees among the 22 were tortured and mistreated at the Lazoughli facility in early 2006, after the men were arrested in February and March:

[SSI] transferred us to Lazoghli for a taste of systematic torture. . . we were beaten up with fists and sticks, and kicked around. [SSI] used electricity on different parts of the body, including sensitive areas.

Attorneys, former detainees, and other sources also indicated that many of the 22 men, while at the Giza facility and at Lazoghli (SSI headquarters), were handcuffed and blindfolded at almost all times during their detention, and described various ill effects on detainees’ mental health, arising both from physical torture and from constant blindfolding.

Former detainees asserted that the apparent purpose of the torture was to coerce the men to confess to the plots that were later described in the April 19 announcement. As one of the former detainees who was held with the group said:

The guys would say they’d be tortured so bad, they’d be screaming, “Tell me what you want me to say! Tell us what to say and we’ll say it!” They’d agree to confirm anything State Security wanted.

The released Victorious Sect detainee quoted above said that several detainees in March and April 2006 “confessed” to criminal acts they had not committed. The detainee said that one detainee held with him falsely admitted “that he was a terrorist,” just after he was shocked with electricity to his penis.

Despite obtaining “confessions,” Egyptian authorities abandoned their prosecution of the men several months after the April 2006 announcement. In August and September 2006, the State Security prosecution office declined to refer any the cases to court, as noted above, and issued orders that all of the men should be released. But most of the men were not released at that point. The Interior Ministry made no public announcement about the mid-2007 release orders, and SSI officers appear to have obtained new detention orders for most of the men (a legal maneuver based on the Emergency Law, not uncommon in Egypt) and transferred them back to prison. Although several were later released in mid and late 2007, at least ten remained in custody as of late 2007.

The purpose of this report is not just to describe the experience of this particular group of men at the hands of the SSI. Rather, it is a case study offered to illustrate how SSI operates across Egypt more generally. Based on our research into SSI operations over the last five years and our extensive interviews with attorneys for other detainees, there is a strong basis to conclude that abuses similar to those suffered by this group of 22 men have occurred in other cases.

Moreover, there is every reason to believe that similar abuses will occur in the future. Numerous observers told Human Rights Watch that SSI in recent years has focused increasingly on young men, and apparent Salafists (devout Muslims) in particular, often arresting and interrogating them without legitimate legal grounds.

Ahmad Saif al-Islam, an attorney who regularly represents families of individuals in SSI custody, explained that SSI routinely arrests or summons Salafists for interrogation. He said: “The police round up random people, then refer people to State Security. . . . [or] sometimes they [SSI] target the Salafists.” According to Saif al-Islam as well as other attorneys, SSI officers typically press suspects to name other men for them to arrest:

They arrest any person they think might take part in some plot, no matter how vague. Also, any time they try to arrest a person and they can’t find them, they arrest someone else. For instance, let’s say they want to arrest a guy named Zain, and they don’t find him. Then they arrest his brother, his father, even a wife.

Observers also said that SSI routinely coerces detainees into becoming informants.

SSI officers who engage in abuse are rarely held to account. A top Egyptian Interior Ministry official, in meetings with Human Rights Watch in February 2004 and February 2005, stated that the government has undertaken no criminal investigations or disciplinary measures in response to allegations of torture and ill-treatment by SSI officers since 1986.5

Egyptian attorneys and human rights activists tell Human Rights Watch that SSI officers continue to operate with impunity across Egypt and are only rarely held accountable for their abusive practices.

This report is meant to draw attention to that impunity. A set of recommendations to the Egyptian government is provided at the end of this report.

1 See Middle East News Agency (Egypt), “Egypt Foreign Ministry reports foiling of terror plot,” April 19, 2006; “Egypt foils terror bombing attempt ,” Xinhua, April 19, 2006; Challiss McDonough, “Egypt Says Terror Group Broken Up,” Voice of America, April 19, 2006; Jonathan Wright, “Egypt says arrests group planning bombings,” Reuters, April 19, 2006; Associated Press, “Egypt arrests 22 on suspicion of plotting terrorist attacks,” April 19, 2006; National Public Radio (US), “Militant Bombing Plot Foiled, Egyptians Say,” broadcast April 19, 2006; Heba Saleh, “Egypt seizes group accused of plot to bomb tourist sites,” Financial Times (UK), April 20, 2006.

2 State Security Investigations (SSI), or Mabahith Amn al-Dawla, is often referred to by Egyptians as “SSI,” or simply as “State Security.”

3 See, for instance, Bryan Bender, “Attacks Signal Stepped-Up Qaeda Effort,” Boston Globe, April 28, 2006.

4 Murad Al-shishani, “Egypt Breaks-up al-Ta"efa al-Mansoura Jihadist Group,” Jamestown Foundation Terrorism Focus, Volume 3, Issue 16, April 25, 2006, available at http://jamestown.org/terrorism/news/article.php?articleid=2369971 (accessed October 15, 2007); Ely Karmon, “Egypt as a New Front of al-Qaeda,” International Institute for Counter-terrorism, May 5, 2006, available at http://www.ict.org.il/apage/5179.php (accessed July 15, 2007). The term “Salafi Jihadism” should not be confused with the term “Salafism” which refers to a particular conservative Islamist ideology. See footnote 7.

5 The meetings were with Gen Ahmad `Umar Abu al-Sa`ud, a member of the cabinet of Minister of Interior  Habib al-`Adli, on February 28, 2004, and February 22, 2005, in Cairo.

Anatomy of a State Security Case

The “Victorious Sect” Arrests




Political opposition and violence in Egypt

Egypt’s State Security Investigations

The Emergency Law

Proposed New Counterterrorism Law

The Case of the “Victorious Sect”

The Announcement of the “Victorious Sect” Arrests

The Actual Arrests

Detention, Torture, and Confessions

Prosecution Dropped

The Timing: A Connection to Egypt’s Emergency Law?

A Larger Pattern of Abuse

Past Allegations of Fabricated Cases

Estimates of the Scale of SSI Detention

Abuse So Routine, It No Longer Shocks

The Weaknesses of Egypt’s Approach to Fighting Terrorism


Appendix: Letters to Egyptian Government Offices


December 2007 Volume 19, No. 9(E)


Related Material

Download PDF of this report
(87 pages, 441 kb )

Download PDF of report with cover
(89 pages, 567 kb )

Also available in:    arabic

Purchase a printed version of this report online

More on Human Rights Watch"s work on Egypt

More on Human Rights Watch"s work on Counterterrorism

Posted in Human Rights , Prisoners of Conscience  
Related Articles
UN rights envoy suspects CIA of Guantanamo torture
CIA Destroyed Torture Tapes Despite Court Orders
Torture and torment in 2007 AD
Rights Watch Demands Egyptian Regime Stop Torturing Political Prisoners
Blacklist of Egyptian Torture Officers Issued
Human Rights Watch Accuses Egypt of Torturing Detainees
9 MB Al-Azhar Students Released, Reportedly Tortured
Al-Azhar Students Tortured, 9 Released Then
YouTube shuts down Egyptian anti-torture activist’s account
Officer Who Tortured Citizen Gets 7 Years
Officer Who Tortured Citizen Gets 7 Years
Torture in Egypt.. overview
YouTube stops account of Egypt anti-torture activist
Egyptian Bloggers Reject Torture in Own Film Festival
MB Bloc Calls for Activating Society’s Role to Stop Torture
Karim Amer Tortured in Borg Alarab prison Demands to the Prosecutor-General to investigate the issue
Three police officers indicted in Qalubiya torture case
Outsourcing Torture
Torturing Palestinian Detainees
2 Police Officers Torture 5 Children, Force them to Sodomize Each other in Police Station
Blogger Karim Amer Tortured in Burj Al-Arab Prison
Egyptian Citizen Dies of Torture in Police Station
Torture.. When it’s turn into a technique
BACKGROUND: ’Dirty and seamless’: Egypt’s torture is our torture (Chris Hedges)
Outsourcing Torture
Egyptian bloggers expose horror of police torture
The Un-American Way of Torture
Egyptian bloggers expose horror of police torture
Promises of Hunting Torture Suspected Officers in Al Fayyum Victim’s Conference
Al Fayyum Police Torture Citizen to Death, Families Refuses to Take Body
Hamido Tortured to death by Egyptian Police
New Torture Incident Committed by Egyptian Police
"Egyptians against Torture" to Kick off
Exclusive to Ikhwanweb: Footage of Torturing Citizen in front Al-Haram Police Station
Exclusive to Ikhwanweb, Video showing the tortured child -Mohamed Mamdouh-
Aljazeera.net Poll: Torture in Egypt a Systematic Policy
12 yrs Child Tortured to Death by Policemen
When will torture in Egypt end?
Giza Citizen Tortured, Killed
Islamists accuse Egypt police of kidnap, torture
New Torture Case in New Cairo Police Station
Egyptian Police Torture Dakahlia Citizen to Death
The Torture of 6 Boys,Kafr Alzayat,Gharbia
The Brotherhood’s Legislatives Launch a Severe Campaign on Torture
Calls for Combating Torture at Police Stations
The Interior Minister Faces Inquiry on Torture
Justice Ministry Admits Torture Cases
The Egyptian Parliament Tackles Torture Issues
The Brotherhood’s MP Asks for Reply on Torture Instance
New Torture Scandal in Police Stations
New Episode of Torture in Police Stations
Egypt tortures for the US, so why not on its own account?
Torture and Silence: This Year’s Arab Spring?
Egypt: AOHR Discusses Prison Torture Crimes Before Parliament
Protests Planned In Response To Alleged Torture
Popular Tribunal To Try Police Officers Accused of Torture
Who Stands behind torture in Egypt ?
Int’l of Torture: The Documents the Crown Would Like to Censor
Israel Plans Torture Center for Abducted Lebanese
Jordan accused of torturing suspects for U.S.
PA Minister: PLC speaker was tortured by Israelis
EOHR: 81 Died Under Torture in Police Custody in 5 Years
Palestinian Abductees: Torture Expression of Jewish Sadism
Sinai torture fields
Torture by degrees
Torture videos to be investigated?
Egypt: Citizen Tortured by State Security Agents in Al Fayyum
Egypt: MB Condemns Tortures Against Members in Menoufeya
FEATURE-Egypt Internet video sharpens torture debate
Kafr Al-Sheikh citizen tortured, threatened with raping wife
HRW to Egypt: Hold Police Accountable for Torture
Al-Wadi Al-Gadid Detainees commit suicide to escape torture
An Egyptian Police Torture Story
Boulaq torturers to be tried 9 January
Egyptian police torture woman detainee (Videos)
MB MPs Lodge Urgent Statements over Latest Detentions, Warn of Torturing Detainees
Amnisty International: Four Tunisians risk torture on return
Partial Blacklist of Egyptian Police Officers Accused of Torture
Salsabeel Comp. Detained Employees Released after State Security Tortures
Torture victim receives 3 months in prison for “resisting authorities”!
Marking 4th Anniversary of Torturing State Security Detainee No.25
Torture Me If You Can
Egypt bloggers reveal new torture case
Bloggers, Kifaya and Ikhwanweb Against Torture
El-Adly Video-Gate: Imbaba Police Detain Torture Victim’s Father
Egyptian Security Storms House of Torture Victim, Detains Wife, Father
Egypt: Officer Who Tortured, Killed Citizen Appears Before Trial Today
Torture video sparks outrage
Yet another face of torture
Tortured then Threatened to keep quite
These Moderates Are in Fact Fanatics, Torturers and Killers
Man claims torture in Egypt after refugee claim turned down
Ghost Plane: The True Story of the CIA Torture Program
263 Torture Cases in Egyptian Police Stations in 6 Yrs: Rights Organization
The US psychological torture system is finally on trial
New Torture Video Revealed In Egypt
Egypt in the dock over tactics of police torturers
Egyptian MP: Torture Is Systematic Under Current Regime
Egypt: Citizen Handicapped in Upper Limbs Due to Prison Torture
Bloggers and Rights Activists Against Torture Meeting
HRW to Mubarak’s regime: Investigate police torture, rape of blogger Sharqawi
Fighting Torture with Mobile Phones and Weblogs
Anti-torture activists: Mubarak’s police knows no limit
Tortured 11 Yrs Ago In Egypt
Wives of Egyptian Detainees Accuse Interior Ministry of Torturing Husbands
MPs Accuse Gov’t of Turning Police Stations Into Torture Centers
Saudi Arabia: New Video Confirms Torture in Prison
Brotherhood Parliamentarian Demands Ousting Interior Minister Over Torture
Egypt: TV journalist detained for denouncing torture
State Security Detains, Tortures 8 Al-Azhar Students
Security Forces Torture, Sexually Harass Luxor Family
Egyptian Citizen Tortured To Death Inside Police Station
Kafr Al-Sheikh Brotherhood Member Tortured By SSF
Gharbiya Citizen Tortured Till Deafness
Egypt Joins Human Rights Council... With More Tortures
Police Tortured MB Students During Thier Detention
A Visit to Fatah’s Torture Chamber
El-Adly Audiogate: Confessions of a Police Torturer
Egypt’s Tortures: Whole Family Tortured in Sharqiya
Abu Zuhri: Gaza Detentions, Tortures Groundless Claims
Egypt: Gov’t Blocks Ikhwanweb After Exposing Torture Cases
State Security Arrest, Torture Son Of Dakahlia Detainee
Egyptian report denounces torture
The Fourth Anniversary of the Torture of Detainee #25
Torture Victim Kidnapped To Prevent Airing His Story On TV Show
MB MP Accuses Interior Ministry of Turing Police Stations Into Torture Centers
Call for release of blogger who reports on torture of detainees
Defendants In Al Azhar Explosions Case Accuse Gov’t of Torture
Torture did not break him, so they detained him again
Egyptian Interior Ministry Acknowledges Police Torture Cases
More Torture Victims In Egypt
Tortured Tunisian Sends Message from Prison