Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
West Bank Bantustan
West Bank Bantustan
Since the only Palestinian ’state’ the current peace process can deliver is another Gaza-style enclave, this upsurge of violence is hardly encouraging
Monday, January 21,2008 11:49
by Ben White information clearing house

"The Guardian" -- Once more, there has been an upsurge of violence in the Gaza Strip. Israeli military attacks have killed over 30 Palestinians in the last few days, while in the neighbouring Israeli city of Sderot and across the Negev, Palestinian rockets have fallen in their dozens.

At the same time, however, there is also a renewed emphasis on negotiations - it was only Monday that Israelis and Palestinians began to discuss issues such as Jerusalem, Palestinian refugees, and the borders of the proposed Palestinian state. Most of the media coverage this week has dealt with these parallel stories by referring to the fresh bloodshed as coming "despite" the "renewed peace talks", or as representing an ill-timed challenge to the successful continuation of the top-level meetings.

The IDF operations and rocket attacks are indeed linked to the so-called peace process, but not in the way that most have suggested. One cannot divorce events in Gaza and Sderot from the Annapolis agenda since, in fact, far from being a threatening interruption to Olmert-Abbas talks, the violence is sadly a natural extension of Roadmap logic.

First, let us remember the context for Israel"s self-declared "disengagement" from the Gaza Strip in 2005. The spectacle of Israeli soldiers dragging away screaming settlers, an image which apparently symbolised the rift in Israeli society between those willing to compromise and the religious extremists, was a useful smokescreen for the openly-stated motivations for the redeployment. From then prime minister, Ariel Sharon, to veteran statesmen like Shimon Peres and US negotiator Dennis Ross, it was explained that disengagement was about demographics, the term preferred in polite conversation for the reality that Palestinians are considered a strategic threat on account of their race.

As Sharon"s advisor, Dov Weisglass, made clear, disengagement was all about putting the peace process in "formaldehyde". Talking to Ha"aretz newspaper, Weisglass boasted how disengagement legitimised "our contention that there is no negotiating with the Palestinians", and moreover:

"... in regard to the large settlement blocs, thanks to the disengagement plan, we have in our hands a first-ever American statement that they will be part of Israel ... Sharon can tell the leaders of the settlers that he is evacuating 10,000 settlers and in the future he will be compelled to evacuate another 10,000, but he is strengthening the other 200,000, strengthening their hold in the soil."

The acknowledgement that there would have to be a future token removal of settlers in the West Bank brings us right up to date with post-Annapolis theatrics, as Bush hurried to Israel urging Olmert to get serious about those hill top trailer outposts. While in Jerusalem, the US president outlined his two-state vision that unites everyone from the Israeli political establishment and Abbas"s clique, to Blair and western liberals. Broadly speaking, it means recognition of Israeli West Bank colonisation, the preservation of Israel"s right to discriminate against non-Jews, and the creation of more sealed-off, "autonomous" Palestinian homelands.

It is a recipe for the creation of more, post-disengagement "Gazas". Proposals such as those made by former IDF deputy chief of staff and advisor to Barak and Sharon, Uzi Dayan, call for a West Bank "disengagement" to protect Israel"s "Jewish-democratic character". It"s the same "more land, fewer Arabs" mantra and, as Dayan"s map shows, it means unilateral Israeli annexation of huge chunks of the West Bank and the creation of Palestinian bantustans.

Like today"s beseiged Gaza, where residents dig up roads for the cement to make graves, these artifical statelets will be subjected to the same kind of treatment urged by commentators such as Gilad Sharon, writing today in leading Israeli paper Yediot Aharanot:

"Even if ultimately we are forced to embark on a broad Gaza operation, we must not approach it as if it"s a surgical operation requiring microscopic levels of accuracy ... We must tell Gaza residents: "One way or another, quiet will prevail here. You can choose whether this will be done through sitting in the darkness or through turning your backyards into ruins.""

The current bloodshed in Gaza, then, is a warning that the current peace paradigm is only likely to reproduce the misery felt by Gazans and the Israelis of Sderot. The Annapolis peace process, guided by the Quartet, leads us towards a Palestinian "state" that, notwithstanding Bush"s adjectival outpourings, will resemble Gaza-esque enclaves declared "unoccupied" and subjected to brutal repression. Israelis and, even more so, Palestinians will be set for yet more of the kind of violence and suffering ushered in by the Gaza disengagement, as witnessed once again this week.

Ben White is a writer living in Sao Paulo, Brazil. He has spent several summers in Palestine/Israel based in the West Bank and written extensively on the Middle East.

His website is at www.benwhite.org.uk and his blog at www.benwhite.org.uk/blog

Posted in Palestine  
Related Articles
World Protests Gaza "siege"
Rights org: Gaza situation potentially disastrous
UNRWA director addresses urgent appeal to save Gaza
Mishaal calls on Arab and Islamic nation to act urgently to save the Gaza people
European hospital in Gaza halts surgeries after electricity blackout
Khudari: Gaza on the brink of human disaster
Power Outages in Gaza, Hamas Blames Arab Nations
Gaza power cuts leave people cold physically, metaphorically
Morgantini lashes out at EU silence towards Gaza massacres
Israeli air strike kills mother and her two sons in Gaza
Mishaal: Bush is fully responsible for the Israeli massacre in Gaza
PRC commander, wife killed in IOF aerial strike on Gaza
Mousa calls on Arabs to break Gaza siege
Na’im: Wounded Palestinians are dying in Gaza hospitals
IOF troops commit new crime in Gaza, kill two more Palestinians
UN coordinator: Situation in Gaza "tragic and serious"
15 martyred including Al-Zahar’s son in Gaza attack
Al-Zahar Threatens, Abbas Condemns IOF Aggression on Gaza
A Statement by the MB Parliamentary Bloc On Gaza Massacre
Bahar: Bush’s visit might herald large-scale IOF invasion of Gaza
Demonstrations in Gaza , Pessimism Over Bush’s MidEast Visit
PSL organizes symbolic funeral for Gaza siege victims
Khudari calls on EU officials to pressure Israel to supply Gaza with fuel
Two others Gazan patients die bringing to 65 the number of siege victims
Muslim Brotherhood Demands Gaza Blockade Lifted
Palestinian teen killed at hands of invading IOF troops in central Gaza
Palestinians killed in Gaza raids
Palestinian will prevails as Gaza pilgrims head home through Rafah gate
Six martyrs in Gaza to coincide with Abbas – Olmert meeting
MB Parliamentarians Demand Gov’t End Gaza Blockade
Mishaal calls Abbas, stresses political partnership