Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Reform Issues
Egypt’s Local Elections Farce: Causes and Consequences
Egypt’s Local Elections Farce: Causes and Consequences
The Egyptian government’s crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood in advance of the April 8 local elections was motivated by its determination to exclude the Brotherhood from the 2011 presidential election and is likely to persist until the matter of presidential succession is settled, argue two Carnegie experts.
Wednesday, May 7,2008 17:29
by Amr Hamzawy, Mohammed Herzallah Carnegie Endowment

The Egyptian government’s crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood in advance of the April 8 local elections was motivated by its determination to exclude the Brotherhood from the 2011 presidential election and is likely to persist until the matter of presidential succession is settled, argue two Carnegie experts.

In Egypt’s Local Elections Farce: Causes and Consequences, Carnegie’s Amr Hamzawy and Mohammed Herzallah argue that Egypt’s controversial April 8 elections underscore the present backward slide and a broad deterioration in Egyptian politics. 

Key points:

• Current social and political unrest in Egypt is not the consequence of reform driven activism like that of 2004 and 2005, but a reaction to worsening economic conditions by independent and discordant activists. The regime’s repressive response—using security forces and various coercive methods to preempt or smother strikes—has failed to stabilize the street. The decentralized nature of these protests makes it more difficult for the regime to contain them, but also prevents the formation of a cohesive opposition movement with clear objectives.
• The regime has consistently failed to resolve the problems of relentless inflation, high unemployment, and crippled welfare system in the country. Minor steps taken by the government continue to fall short of the comprehensive social and economic reform needed.
• The Egyptian regime’s return to authoritarian methods impairs organized political opposition in the country, which in turn erodes the prospects of sustainable national and political recovery. But opposition forces are also partly responsible for their present condition. Their lack of credibility and discipline has undermined their ability to establish a reliable opposition front.
• The Brotherhood’s last-minute boycott of the local elections revealed the movement’s lack of consistency in its strategic thinking. The Brotherhood’s decision to boycott these elections conspicuously contradicts its previous commitment to advancing reform through political participation at all costs.

Reflecting on the Brotherhood’s boycott, the authors strike a cautionary note on the consequences.

“To the degree that the movement intended to retaliate for the regime’s flagrant actions, its decision may not pay off. After all, keeping the Muslim Brotherhood out of the local councils was the intention of the ruling establishment in the first place. What’s more, the movement is setting a dangerous precedent that the regime will certainly keep in mind: through sufficient political persecution and repression, the authorities can count on the Brotherhood to take itself voluntarily out the political equation,” they conclude.

Full Text (PDF)


Posted in Reform Issues , Human Rights  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Despite the end of Municipal Elections,Prolonging jail terms for 15 MB members
MB Bloc: Victory of Non-Candidates in Local Elections Reveals Regime’s Fraud
egypt: Controversial local elections
Egypt’s Local Elections Farce
Egypt: Elections and Future of the Muslim Brotherhood
US expresses concerns over Egyptian elections
Muslim Brotherhood to boycott election
Khalil Anani: MB Boycott Annulls Elections
Low Turnout and Vote Rigging Mar Municipal Elections, Ikhwanweb Reports
Muslim Brotherhood Statement on Local Election Boycott
Egypt: Muslim Brotherhood opposition group urges boycott of municipal elections
Muslim Brotherhood to Boycott Local Elections in Egypt After Crackdown
Tuesday: Egypt Local Elections Without Opposition
Egypt Police Arrests 12 year Old Boy on the Eve of Local Elections
Muslim Brotherhood Withdraws From Municipal Elections, Calls on Egyptians to Boycott the Vote
Habib: Tuesday’s Local Elections "A Farce"
April 8 Local Elections Annulled in more Cities in Egypt
Ghozlan: Egyptian Regime Cannot Compete With MB in Transparent Elections
Egypt: Municipal elections on Tuesday 8 April, concerns mount
MB Parliamentary Bloc to Hold Press Conference on Local Elections Monday
Egypt Administrative Courts Annull April 8 Local Elections
Egypt arrests 34 Muslim Brotherhood members ahead of elections and general strike
Egypt: Jailing 800 Activists Casts Doubt on Elections
Only Twenty Muslim Brotherhood Candidates to Run in Local Election
Muslim Brotherhood MP Condemns Gov’t Violence Dealing With Candidates For Municipal Elections
Egypt: Local Elections…the End of the Democratic Spring
Egypt’s Interior Minister Vows to Bar MB Candidates From Running in Municipal Elections
Hundreds of Muslim Brotherhood members clash with police ahead of municipal elections
MB Stages Several Protests Across Egypt Condemning Municipal Elections Violations
Sweeps of Arrests Continue as Municipal Elections Approach
Court Verdict allowing 100 MB candidate to be registered in elections