Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Prisoners of Conscience
Internet No Automatic Revolution
Internet No Automatic Revolution
Egypt has detained a number of its citizens for using the social networking site Facebook to organize anti-government protests. What online sites are most effective in influencing politics -- and is the impact positive?
Saturday, May 24,2008 17:35
by Anwer Sher WashingtonPost

The Current Discussion: Egypt has detained a number of its citizens for using the social networking site Facebook to organize anti-government protests. What online sites are most effective in influencing politics -- and is the impact positive?

In the context of Egypt, the government’s reaction to the use of sites like Facebook to influence politics within the country forms a broader pattern of media control. In essence Facebook, Hi5, and other social networking communities do get the wrath of governments on the basis of alleged erosion of "social values". This is a delicate subject for most of the emerging world, but I am not entirely sure that Facebook, per se, is known for being a platform for political dissent. For instance, the entire protest against General Musharraf"s handling of Pakistan’s Judiciary, while absolutely high-handed, has not been reflected in places like Facebook. Yet blogs, other internet sites and even email e-blogs have become more effective mainly because they remain more targeted.

As far as the internet media is concerned, it’s becoming more powerful, especially with the ease of net traffic and of course more flexibility in content presentation. However, in a number of cases even the more serious political platforms on the internet have questionable effectiveness as instruments of direct change. Burma, Tibet, Iraq, the Arab World, Israel’s behavior and American insensitivity to world opinion – all have figured in various prestigious platforms. The result has been that while people may end up being better informed, I am not sure they are willing to do much more about it than perhaps an occasional protest email.

Take the example of PostGlobal itself. While there is no doubt this forum has a respected readership, there is perhaps, judging by some reader comments, a tendency to only read the headline and the first paragraph and then leave a comment. (To use my last post as an example, some readers felt I was asking only the Arabs to accept Israel, when I was additionally arguing that Israel has to stop its inhuman treatment of the Arabs and even quoted Amnesty International.) So on balance, the situation is not as simple as saying that if it’s on the Internet, it will influence opinion. It is more likely that it will shape some opinions, but unless the leadership or the audience that needs to act is really going to take serious note of the media on the net, I would argue that it will still be some time before we can say that Internet-based opinions matter. Perhaps this is because of the fractured nature of the Internet, and because I can hardly see General Musharraf, President Bush or Hosni Mubarak waking up each morning and reading the hundreds of blogs out in cyberspace.

Nevertheless, for those who care and do understand the writers’ complete arguments, there is a case that it can provide the basis for interaction and perhaps eventually action.

Posted in Prisoners of Conscience , Human Rights  
Related Articles
Internet Alone Won’t Change Politics
Arab Bloggers Keep Watch Over Government – And Each Other
Anti—NDP bloggers call the MB to deal differently with the regime
Egypt: Torture for Bloggers and Activists
How the internet is challenging Egypt’s government
Egypt: Second Generation Internet Users and Political Change
Blogging the strike: activists remain behind bars
Brotherhood blogger prevented from leaving the country
Bloggers Call for Coordination Among Opposition for May 4 Strike
Bloggers call for "Public Tribunal" for 40 Egyptian Officials
Internet Campaign in Egypt to Boycott National Newspapers
Bloggers Call for Dropping Egypt ’s Ruling NDP in Municipal Elections
The Internet as a global village for Arab activists
Mideast censors limiting the Internet
The lawsuit demanding the websites banning in Egypt is rejected with the emphasis on the Internet
Middle East censors seek to limit access to Internet
Saturday, December 29, 2007 A very important court sentence will affect the internet future in Egypt
The list of 13 Internet enemies
Web users at internet cafes allegedly under the radar of state security, says blogger
Implacable Adversaries …Arab Gov’ts and the Internet
Interior minister warns Egyptians against using Internet to jeopardize national security
As a blogger is jailed, promises that the internet would challenge dictators have proved illusory
Internet Freedom in the Middle East: Challenges for U.S. Policy
Internet as a Forum for Conflict Between MB and Al-Qaida