Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Political Islam Studies
’Islamists edge towards democracy’
’Islamists edge towards democracy’
Islamic political movements in the Middle East and Asia are becoming increasingly democratic. That is the conclusion reached at a conference on ’post-Islamism’ in Leiden. But not everyone is prepared to simply trust the Islamists now that they are talking democracy.
Sunday, September 28,2008 12:27
by www.radionetherlands.nl ,Michel Hoebink*

Islamic political movements in the Middle East and Asia are becoming increasingly democratic. That is the conclusion reached at a conference on "post-Islamism" in Leiden. But not everyone is prepared to simply trust the Islamists now that they are talking democracy.

It is a striking paradox. Countries such as the United States are becoming less keen on the notion of democratisation in the Islamic world, amid fears that elections would only bring the Islamists to power. Meanwhile, the Islamists themselves are viewing democracy with increasing enthusiasm.

Less radical
Throughout the Islamic world - from
Morocco to Indonesia - it is becoming more common for Islamic political movements to take part in the democratic process, becoming less radical in their views as a result. Asef Bayat, director of Leiden"s International Institute for the Study of Islam in the Modern World (ISIM), refers to this trend as "post-Islamism". "Islam remains an important source of inspiration for these movements but religion is seen less and less as being in conflict with modern ideals of democracy and human rights."

Two years ago, the Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy (WRR) published a report in which it pointed out this development and advised the Dutch government to initiate a dialogue with moderate Islamic political movements. The report did not have much in the way of impact: the Netherlands still refuses to have any contact with movements such as Hezbollah and Hamas.

A country at the forefront of this trend towards democratic Islamism is
Turkey, where the ruling AK Party seems to have developed into something like an Islamic counterpart to the Christian Democratic parties of Europe. "The AK Party has even begun to praise secularism", explains researcher Ihsan Dagi of the Middle East Technical University in Ankara. "The Turkish state believes in a radical form of secularism, one that is used as an instrument to exclude the Islamists. The AK Party has responded to this by advocating an Anglo-Saxon form of secularism, which says that the state has to be neutral with regard to religion."

Hamas in the Palestinian Territories, Hezbollah in Lebanon and Islamist movements in Morocco, Egypt, Indonesia and Pakistan are increasingly letting go of the idea that an Islamic state should be one which Islamises society with an iron hand. The notion that there is only one authoritative interpretation of Islam is making way for pluralism; the call for a literal implementation of Islamic law is being replaced by a historical vision of the sources of revelation, the origins of the religion.

In power
How genuine are the Islamists in flirting with democratic principles? Will they still honour such principles once they have come to power by democratic means? In the West and among secular groups in the Islamic world, mistrust of the Islamists continues to run deep. And there is some evidence to support such sentiments. In countries like
Iran, Sudan and Saudi Arabia, where Islamism is in power, repression is the order of the day.

Religious authority 
Yet post-Islamism is also developing in those countries where Islamism is in power. "As soon as the Islamists come to power", argues Abdelwahab El-Affendi of the
University of Westminster in the UK, "the problem of religious authority arises. Other groups emerge to challenge the religious authority of the ruling powers and claim to represent true Islam." According to El-Affendi, this should ultimately lead to the insight that Islam can be interpreted in different ways and that a form of democratic government is the best way to allow these various interpretations to compete with one another.

Asef Bayat believes this is exactly what happened in the 1990s in Iran. "Disappointment with the regime of the Ayatollahs led to a major public debate about the role of Islam in the state and society and to the emergence of a "post-Islamist" reform movement." That reform movement has been suppressed since President Ahmadinejad came to power. But Bayat is convinced that in the end it will prove to have been the start of an irreversible shift in the direction of post-Islamism.


Posted in Political Islam Studies  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Reuters: Egypt’s Islamists Sees Election Setback in 2010
Mauritania Islamists: Military Coup Threatens the Country’s Stability
Islamists gain from Mideast turmoil and democratic deficit
Arab Islamists, their internal democracy
Reform between Islamists, Secularists
The West and the Islamists
US/INTERNATIONAL: Dialogue with Islamists
Islamists win seats in Kuwait Parliamentary poll
Why Islamists Don’t Win Elections
Political Islam and Democracy - What do Islamists and Islamic Movements want?
EGYPT: Islamists Given Jail, and a Message
Ikhwanweb Featured in BBC Report: Egypt Islamists Wait for Power
Morocco Islamists Harassed by Security Services
Campaigning for all (including Islamists)
Egypt Islamists in Hiding Ahead of Vote
Egypt Islamists fight obstacles to enter council vote
What it means... Yemeni Islamists’ stance on democracy
Political Islam and Democracy - What do Islamists and Islamic Movements want?
Let’s not forget the moderate Islamists
Analysis: Not all Islamists are equal
Workshop on Islamists Future in Arab Parliaments
Islamists emerge in stifled Tunisia
Egyptian court drops terrorism charges against Islamists
Elections in Jordan: Poor Showing for Islamists
Moderate Islamists and peaceful democracy
In Focus: The Autumn of Arab Islamists
Why are Western officials hesitant to talk to moderate Islamists ?
Jordan’s Islamists Seek Offices Their Allies Scorn
What today’s Islamists Want
Looking for Moderate Islamists
Turkish Paradox: Progressive Islamists versus Reactionary Secularists
Do not undermine moderate Islamists: The case of Muslim Brotherhood leader, Khayrat El-Shater
Success of Turkey’s AK Party must not dilute worries over Arab Islamists
Moroccan Elections: A new rise for Islamists?
Turkey, Palestine, Morocco: No Welcome to Islamists
A shift in the thinking of Egyptian Islamists
Islamists under fire draft first political programme