Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Islamic Movements
Arab democracy needs ‘Islamist revision’
Arab democracy needs ‘Islamist revision’
Muslim societies typically divide into three broad blocs, suggests Bret Stephens: a “pre-modern” element of tribesmen, peasants, nomads, and the like; a “modern” element - the Arab Center - the urban, educated middle-class; and an “anti-modern” elements, comprising Islamists but also members of Baathist and other fascistic groups.
Tuesday, September 30,2008 15:52
Demdigest.net

Islamic movements in the Arab world should undertake a “radical intellectual revision” and abandon the “dogmatic” idea of a religious state, leading Arab analysts argue.

“Any Islamic state would have a problem with democracy because Islamists seek to create a religious state in which the infallible Islamic Sharia would replace the law though Sharia is merely a way of life,” said Radwan al-Sayed, professor of Islamic Studies at Lebanon University. Addressing a seminar organized by the Doha-based Arab Democracy Foundation, he condemned Hamas and Hezbollah party for resorting to violence. Hamas has “relapsed into violence against the Palestinians who voted for it”, while Hezbollah deployed “just to obtain more advantages over rival factions,” he said.

Arab regimes were responsible for “the weakening of the religious institutions”, creating a vacuum which Islamists sought to fill. “A main obstacle to democratisation in the Arab countries is the ruling regimes themselves,” he explained. “They suppress all the civil society movements including the Islamists.
He was supported by Tunisian analyst Salah al-Din al-Jurashi who called on Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood to abandon its slogan “Islam is the solution” which implies a “monopoly of Islam”.

“I hope that Islamists can give up the idea that application of the Sharia will solve all the problems of our societies and do some sort of calm revision of their approaches,” he said. “Without a radical revision made by Islamists, a relapse would remain possible.”

Muslim societies typically divide into three broad blocs, suggests Bret Stephens: a “pre-modern” element of tribesmen, peasants, nomads, and the like; a “modern” element - the Arab Center - the urban, educated middle-class; and an “anti-modern” elements, comprising Islamists but also members of Baathist and other fascistic groups.

So far, he argues, many democracy-promotion efforts have targeted the middle, most familiar group. “But this is not, in all cases, politically the most consequential element,” Stephens argues. “What we have learned in Iraq is that it is possible, indeed necessary, to isolate anti-moderns by creating political alliances between the urban middle class and the tribes.”


Posted in Islamic Movements  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
’Islamists edge towards democracy’
Islamist Parties and Democracy: Three Kinds of Movements
Reuters: Egypt’s Islamists Sees Election Setback in 2010
Mauritania Islamists: Military Coup Threatens the Country’s Stability
Party Leader Says Islamist Trend is Fact in Mauritania, Other Countries
Islamists gain from Mideast turmoil and democratic deficit
Arab Islamists, their internal democracy
Reform between Islamists, Secularists
Turkish Islamist Intellectuals at Left-Leaning Crossroads
The West and the Islamists
POMED Notes: Islamist Parties and Democracy
The Islamist Conundrum
EVENT on "Islamist Parties and Democracy"
Experts Urge U.S. to Talk with Islamist Movements to Encourage Democratic Trends
Experts Urge U.S. to Talk with Islamist Movements to Encourage Democratic Trends
US/INTERNATIONAL: Dialogue with Islamists
Islamists win seats in Kuwait Parliamentary poll
Why Islamists Don’t Win Elections
Political Islam and Democracy - What do Islamists and Islamic Movements want?
EGYPT: Islamists Given Jail, and a Message
Jordanian Islamist warns of an unprecedented reaction if Gaza siege persisted
Ikhwanweb Featured in BBC Report: Egypt Islamists Wait for Power
Islamist Group Pressures Egypt’s Ruling Party
In Egypt, Islamist runs against the odds
Morocco Islamists Harassed by Security Services
Campaigning for all (including Islamists)
Egypt bars 90 percent of Islamist hopefuls from vote
Egypt Islamists in Hiding Ahead of Vote
700 potential opposition candidates arrested ahead of Egypt’s elections: Islamist lawmaker
Egypt Islamists fight obstacles to enter council vote
A Moderate Islamist is Arrested in Egypt - and What it Means for Us
What it means... Yemeni Islamists’ stance on democracy
Islamist target Hirsi Ali seeks French protection
Political Islam and Democracy - What do Islamists and Islamic Movements want?
Refusing talk to facilitate talk – the paradox of Islamist dialogue: An overdue task or an exercise
Islamist Movements and the Political Challenge: An Alternate Perspective
Let’s not forget the moderate Islamists
The Islamist opposition online in Egypt and Jordan
The Islamist opposition online in Egypt and Jordan
Analysis: Not all Islamists are equal