Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Human Rights
EGYPT: Doctor jailed and whipped in Saudi Arabia
EGYPT: Doctor jailed and whipped in Saudi Arabia
most 20 ago, Dr. Raouf Arabi flew from his home in Egypt to Saudi Arabia for a job in the world’s richest oil country. It never occured to him that he might end up whipped and in jail.
Monday, November 10,2008 12:30
by Noha El-Hennawy LATimes

Almost 20 ago, Dr. Raouf Arabi flew from his home in Egypt to Saudi Arabia for a job in the world"s richest oil country. It never occured to him that he might end up whipped and in jail.

Several weeks ago, Egyptians awoke to the news that the doctor was sentenced by a Saudi court to seven years in prison and 750 lashes on charges he prescribed high doses of morphine to a Saudi princess, who eventually turned into a drug addict. Upon his appeal, the sentence was doubled to reach 15 years in prison and 1,500 lashes. Egypt then learned that a second Egyptian doctor in the same case was sentenced to 20 years and the same number of lashes.

"How can I breath or take a sip of water while my husband is being whipped in the middle of the street there?" Fatheyya Shehata, Arabi"s wife, said in tears on a private satellite channel this weekend. Shehata denied the allegations brought against her 53-year-old husband.

The incident has provoked rage across Egypt, reigniting questions about the laxity of the government in protecting Egyptian expatriates against the need for Saudi petrodollars.   

Human rights advocate Negad Borai was quoted in the local press as saying: "The Egyptian government feels inferior to Saudi Arabia, and this gives it and other Gulf countries the chance to humiliate Egyptians living there."

Whipping is standard punishment in the Saudi kingdom, whose judicial system follows fundamentalist Wahhabi doctrines. Such practices have long been a bone of contention between Riyadh and international human rights organizations.

"The tragedy of the two Egyptian doctors shows the level of humiliation that Egyptians have become subjected to in and outside Egypt due to the corrupt and unjust ruling regime; however, it also shows the brutality and hypocrisy of alternative religiosity," wrote prominent novelist Alaa Aswany in El Destour weekly.

He continued: "The allegation is valueless and imprecise and needs a specialized impartial medical investigation especially that the princess had been already addicted to drugs before she received treatment from the two doctors. Anyway, any suspect has the right to a fair trial but the Saudi authorities believe that the princess"s complaint is the truth; the princess is held infallible.... If these two doctors were British or American, would the Saudi authorities dare to whip them or arrest them? Of course not, Westerners are treated differently from Arabs and Muslims in Saudi Arabia."

The Egyptian doctor"s syndicate condemned the verdicts as worse than death and addressed a letter to President Hosni Mubarak calling on him to intervene in order to put an end to this tragedy. The association also called for a demonstration next week in protest of the verdict.

"President Mubarak should withdraw the Egyptian ambassador in Saudi Arabia to save the dignity of Egyptians and to respond to this bloody verdict that contradicts God"s laws and logic. Otherwise, the president"s s dignity as well as his people"s would be easy to breach," wrote Mostafa Rashed in a comment posted on the website of the independent daily Al Masry al Youm.

Posted in Human Rights  
Related Articles
Rare Saudi Arabia protest tests limits of political speech
Saudi Arabia’s “Soft” Counterterrorism Strategy: Prevention, Rehabilitation, and Aftercare
Let’s not talk about Saudi Arabia
Al-Jazeera and Saudi Arabia
Saudi Arabia: Free Fouad Update
Remarks With Saudi Arabian Foreign Minister Saud al-Faisal
Mr. Akef Barred From Traveling To Saudi Arabia To Perform Umra.
Saudi Arabia, Egypt and the Middle East: With friends like these
Saudi Arabia: New Video Confirms Torture in Prison
Promoting Democracy and Human Rights in the Middle East: The Case of Saudi Arabia