Deprecated: mysql_connect(): The mysql extension is deprecated and will be removed in the future: use mysqli or PDO instead in /home2/ikhwan/public_html/admin-cp-control/inc/db.php on line 14

Warning: session_start(): Cannot send session cookie - headers already sent by (output started at /home2/ikhwan/public_html/admin-cp-control/inc/db.php:14) in /home2/ikhwan/public_html/article.php on line 6

Warning: session_start(): Cannot send session cache limiter - headers already sent (output started at /home2/ikhwan/public_html/admin-cp-control/inc/db.php:14) in /home2/ikhwan/public_html/article.php on line 6

Deprecated: mysql_connect(): The mysql extension is deprecated and will be removed in the future: use mysqli or PDO instead in /home2/ikhwan/public_html/admin-cp-control/inc/db.php on line 14
The Inappropriateness of Using a Left-Right Spectrum on Foreign Policy - Ikhwanweb

Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Wed926 2018

Last update20:52 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Activites
The Inappropriateness of Using a Left-Right Spectrum on Foreign Policy
The Inappropriateness of Using a Left-Right Spectrum on Foreign Policy
Many of you have probably seen the interesting back-and-forth between Matt Yglesias and Ross Douthat regarding Obama’s foreign policy orientation. I just wanted to comment that, while I understand what Ross is saying, I still find this part somewhat baffling:
Friday, November 21,2008 18:26
by Shadi Hamid Democracy Arsenal

Many of you have probably seen the interesting back-and-forth between Matt Yglesias and Ross Douthat regarding Obama’s foreign policy orientation. I just wanted to comment that, while I understand what Ross is saying, I still find this part somewhat baffling:

Here"s a fearless prediction: On an awful lot of issues, the Obama foreign policy will end cutting to the right of Bill Clinton"s foreign policy, which was already more center-left than left. Even with the GOP brand in the toilet, Republicans are still trusted as much or more than Dems on foreign policy, mostly for somewhat nebulous "toughness" reasons.

It’s never really made sense to me to use a left-right spectrum when talking about foreign policy. What does it mean to have a “leftist” foreign policy approach? I assume that people use “leftist” as a proxy for “weak.” But, even the “weak/dove” – “strong/hawk” spectrum is a weird one. I think the last 8 years would indicate that hawks have made us weaker, while doves would have made us stronger. Is a willingness to coddle dictators a sign of weakness or strength? And if it’s the former, then why do so a significant number of “neo-cons” have, contrary to what their ideology would suggest, a particular fondness for “moderate” Arab dictators? If we’re talking about the left’s foreign policy tradition, then a “moralist” concern with supporting human rights and democracy abroad is, I would say, distinctly “leftist.” But then we run into a problem: democracy promotion > leftist foreign policy approach > weak.

What about caring about what other people think about us? If you say something like, “it would be nice if Arab publics liked us,” you’re apparently weak on national security. But it would seem to me that our ability to fight terrorism would be strengthened if we had the support of target populations. The problem is our whole discourse on foreign policy has been, for some time, shaped by the Right, and many of the definitions we use are products of a post-9/11 sensibility. In other words, much of it is distorted.


Posted in Activites , Human Rights  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Obama’s Palestine choices
Obama, Middle East and the Freedom Agenda
Obama’s win promotes democracy in Arab world
On Obama’s Inherited Freedom Agenda
Obama could change dynamics in the Arab world
Obama’s Essential Reading
MB Did Not Flatter Obama, It Praised A Value, Says MB Secretary General
Muslim Brotherhood Chairman Comments on Obama’s Victory
Qaradawi: I Supported Obama For Change
Obama One More Time
What Moderate Islamists Expect from Obama?
A Historic Opportunity for President-Elect Obama
More on Obama and the Middle East
More on Obama and the Middle East
Obama’s Message Resonates in Egypt - To a Point
Does Obama’s Success Represent A Civilization Value?
Hamas Says it is Ready to Talk to Obama
Obama: don’t surrender to the Jewish lobby
Obama, Emanuel and Israel
Obama and my Grandmother
Europe’s Muslims Urge Obama "Overcome the Mistakes of the Past"
Obama’s freedom agenda?
Welcome to Mideast Peace, President Obama
Obama Appeal in Muslim World May Tone Down Militants (Update2)
Hamas: We’ll judge Obama by his actions not by his electoral agenda
US expatriates, Egyptian locals hail Obama the "American Dream"
Anti-Obama Smears About Religion or Race?
CNN exclusive: Obama on foreign policy
U.S. Jews outraged over phone campaign alleging ’Obama gave money to PLO’
Obama and McCain on 9/11: “unity” in support of war and repression
World wants Obama to be next US president: poll
Biden: Israel will be more protected with Obama
Curb Your Enthusiasm for Obama
Obama camp denies report Biden said Israel will have to reconcile to nuclear Iran
Obama: World must not let Iran corner Israel
Obama choses Biden to make Israel’s supporters happy
The Last Pharaoh will be the biggest challenge to Obama
Open letter to President Obama
150 Clergy Appeal to Obama: Don’t Lose Your Ethical Vision, Don’t Move to the Political Center
After the letter to Obama