Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Human Rights
Abbas has no right to ask Hamas to recognize Israel
Abbas has no right to ask Hamas to recognize Israel
The de facto chairman of the Palestinian Authority (PA) Mahmoud Abbas is once again asking Hamas to recognize Israel as a precondition for the formation of a prospective national unity government
Sunday, March 1,2009 02:58
by Khalid Amayreh PIC&Ikhwanweb

The de facto chairman of the Palestinian Authority (PA)  Mahmoud Abbas is once again asking Hamas to recognize Israel as a precondition for the formation of a prospective national unity  government.

In a speech in Ramallah on Saturday, 28 February, Abbas said any  Palestinian unity government " will have to  be committed to our values and  respect agreements previously signed by the Palestinian Authority.”

Abbas didn’t explicitly say that Hamas would have to recognize Israel. However, this is exactly what every Palestinian listening to his speech  understood from his statements.

Well, it is really sad and lamentable that the Palestinian political discourse has stooped to this level of national apostasy.

Palestinian leaders from time immemorial never stopped urging our masses to resist Zionist aggression, and never give up the dream of earning our freedom from the cruel hands of Zionism.

Hence, the fact that a late comer shamelessly urges his own people to recognize the legitimacy of their oppressors and dispossessors, who have just incinerated hundreds of children in Gaza using  White Phosphorus bombs, is more than demeaning and injurious to our collective national spirit.

First of all, Abbas should realize, in case he doesn’t, that recognizing Israel would mean a full-embrace of the Zionist narrative, a blaspheme by any other name.

It would mean a recognition, or at least an acknowledgement, that Israel had the right to wrest Palestine from its rightful owners by way of employing murder, terror and ethnic cleansing. It would mean that all the massacres and atrocities Israel perpetrated were legitimate.

In other words, Abbas is effectively demanding that Hamas and other Palestinians morph themselves into full-fledged Zionists.

But Israel seeks more than just a mere recognition of its “right to exist.”  The nefarious entity  insists that all  Palestinians (and all Arabs) recognize her  as a Jewish state.

 In real terms, this would imply that the sizeable Palestinian community in Israel, whose existence in their ancestral land,  had preceded the advent of modern Jewish immigration from Eastern Europe  by numerous centuries,  will have to be expelled, partially or wholly, at some point in the future?

So,  one might really wonder if the PA leader is asking Hamas to recognize Israel’s “right” to expel more than 1.5 million Palestinians on the ground that Israel is a “Jewish state” and that non-Jews have only a transient right to live within the state?

Indeed,  one would be stating   the obvious by arguing that neither Abbas, nor Fatah, nor Hamas, not even the 23 Arab kings and presidents-for-life, have the right to speak on behalf of these admirable Palestinians who clang to their homes despite all the harassment and institutionalized persecution meted out to them by  successive Zionist governments.

Apart from Zionist criminality, there are a thousand other reasons why no dignified Palestinian leadership  should not recognize Israel.

The PLO,  which everyone is trying to rehabilitate these days, lost its chastity when it was duped into  recognizing  Israel through the scandalous Oslo Agreement.  And instead of receiving a Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital, as the famous mantra goes,  in exchange for that unethical recognition,  it got more Jewish-only colonies,  narrower horizons for the Palestinian masses and a Nazi-like gigantic wall that effectively transformed Palestinian towns and villages  into open-air prisons.

So, I want to ask Mr. Abbas and his cohorts. Did Israel recognize a viable and sovereign Palestinian state in exchange for that stupid PLO recognition?

I am asking this question because even the stupidest and most demented Palestinian wouldn’t have given Israel a free recognition?

Furthermore, I want to ask you Mr. President, which Israel do  you want Hamas to recognize? Is it Israel according to the partition plan? Is it Israel according to the 1949 armistice agreement? Is it Israel according to the pre-1967 borders? Is it Israel with East  Jerusalem? Is it Israel with the Golan Heights? Is it Israel with Shaba Province? Or is  it Greater Israel which according to some rabbinic authorities  includes Jordan (Eastern Yeretz Yisrael!!), Syria, Lebanon, as well as large parts of Egypt, Iraq and northern Saudi Arabia?

I am posing these questions because until today, Israel has no fixed borders. Didn’t you hear the gurus of Zionism claim during the recent blitzkrieg in Gaza that Israel had the right to prevent any international ship to access the blockaded and thoroughly starved coastal territory?

More to the point, could you tell me Mr. President why a Palestinian government of national unity would have to recognize Israel when the Israeli government refuses to recognize Palestine?

Aren’t you aware that the government which the notorious  pathological liar, Benyamin Netanyahu, is trying to form will include manifestly fascist  parties such as Habayt ha’yahudi (the Jewish Home),  Ichud Leumi (National Union)  Yisrael Beitenu (Israel is our Home) and Shas? Even Netanyahu himself doesn’t believe in a Palestinian state as evident from his vacuous charade about effecting economic prosperity in the West Bank.

You are supposed to be an expert on Zionism and sufficiently  familiar with the Nazi-like ideologies espoused by  these racist parties.

So, why haven’t you insisted on parity and reciprocity with Israel by demanding that the PA wouldn’t negotiate with any Israeli government that doesn’t recognize a truly sovereign  and territorially contiguous Palestinian state on at least  100% of the occupied territories?

I really can’t understand  why the Palestinians have to give up all their “bargaining cards” when Israel continues to kill any realistic  prospects for the creation of  a Palestinian entity that is worthy of the name?

Mr. President, one doesn’t have to be especially smart to tell Hillary Clinton and other western emissaries  that they have no right to demand that Hamas recognize Israel and abandon armed struggle as long as the Israeli government includes fascist political parties that not only deny  our right to freedom and self-determination but also go as far as demanding our enslavement, banishment and even physical extermination.

You may examine their declared and undeclared platforms and see for yourself the evilness of their designs against our people.

Yes, one doesn’t have to have a specially high IQ to utter these most logical words and put up a brave and dignified stance on behalf of our people.  But one does have to be courageous, a character that the present PA leadership obviously doesn’t possess.

Finally, we all know that there is not the slightest chance in hell that Hamas will recognize a Zionist Israel, mainly for religious and moral reasons. A Hamas that recognizes a Zionist Israel simply loses   its raison d’etre.


Posted in Human Rights , Palestine  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
MP Barghouthi castigates Abbas for calling for elections in WB only
Abbas to meet Olmert despite IOF escalation in Gaza
Haneyya government: Abbas’s speech proved his irresponsibility
Hamas: Abbas’s speech full of contradictions, reflects ill will
Hamas deplores Abbas’s grief over future of talks with Olmert
Abbas threatens to resign if peace deal not reached by end of year
Detainees in Abbas’s prisons carried to hospitals
MENA: Abbas, Mubarak to meet on developments in Palestinian territories
Masri: Abbas and his team trade Palestinian blood for political gains
Olmert told Abbas: Settlement expansion to continue
HRW Urges Abbas to punish killers of Majd Barghouthi
Hamas: Abbas’s statements do not represent the Palestinian people’s positions
Abbas’s authority record of crimes against journalists
Hamadan: Hamas could never be in a position of begging for a meeting with Abbas
Abbas Needs a Miracle
Barhoum: Abbas exploits Palestinian suffering to serve occupation
The mission of Cairo resident Wael Abbas is to document abuse and repression, despite the dangers.
Abbas’s authority condemns Dimona bombing
Is Abbas Israel’s lawyer?
Masri: Abbas-Olmert meeting meant to foil Mubarak’s call
What is Mahmoud Abbas waiting for?
Nunu: Abbas’s conditions for dialogue deepen rift, reflect bad intention
Abbas reaches Zahhar over phone, extends condolences
Al-Zahar Threatens, Abbas Condemns IOF Aggression on Gaza
Wael Abbas: the Arab Internet’s unlikely superhero
Abbas fails his Palestinian people; wants Hamas to recognize occupation
Hamas: Abbas-Olmert meetings useless, disastrous to national project
Abbas-Olmert meeting to precede Bush’s visit
Hamas asks Abbas to prove his seriousness and sack Fayyad government
Haneyya calls on Abbas and Fatah to turn new page to restore national unity
Nazzal: Abbas not concerned with national dialogue
Abbas’s troops hand IOF three armed settlers
Six martyrs in Gaza to coincide with Abbas – Olmert meeting
Haniyeh interview:
USA allies with Abbas to topple Palestinian legitimacy
Abbas phones Mishaal over formation of unity government
Egypt transferred large quantity of arms, ammunition to Abbas’ guards
Hamdan: Abbas’ Decrees Add Fuel To Fire
Hamas Rejects Al Qaeda, Rebuts Abbas Claims