Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
Palestine
Palestine and Israel: Time for Plan B
Palestine and Israel: Time for Plan B
Negotiations over a two-state solution to resolve the Israeli–Palestinian conflict have reached a dead end. International efforts should focus on a short-term cease-fire between Israel and Hamas that can pave the way for a sustainable armistice, concludes a new policy brief by Nathan J. Brown
Sunday, March 8,2009 04:29
by Nathan Brown Carnegie Endowment

Negotiations over a two-state solution to resolve the Israeli–Palestinian conflict have reached a dead end. International efforts should focus on a short-term cease-fire between Israel and Hamas that can pave the way for a sustainable armistice, concludes a new policy brief by Nathan J. Brown.

The bitter realities on the ground make an immediate and comprehensive solution to the Israeli–Palestinian conflict unattainable for now. A new diplomatic approach should be based on three steps: first, a properly negotiated cease-fire; second, a medium-term armistice; and finally, addressing the underlying causes of the conflict during the respite.

Key Conclusions:

  • A new cease-fire agreement must be attractive to both sides. Hamas can be enticed with border openings, freedom of operation in Palestinian areas, and a freeze on settlements and Israel with a cessation of attacks from Hamas and other groups, combined with a serious effort to halt arms supplies to Hamas.
     
  • Both have indicated interest in an armistice, but credibility and trust issues must be addressed. Palestinians need assurances that an armistice will not become a permanent solution and Israel must believe that Hamas will not use the time for a military build-up.
     
  • Enforcement mechanisms—settlement monitoring and border inspections—are key to the armistice.
     
  • The United States should encourage rather than discourage European and Arab efforts to lead negotiations among Palestinians and between Palestinians and Israelis.
     
  • A period of relative stability for five to ten years under the armistice could serve as a platform to address the underlying causes of the conflict. Paramount in this stage will be rebuilding Palestinian institutions and democracy.

Brown concludes:

“Acknowledging and working with existing realities must not, however, mean accepting them as permanent. The existing situation is not only short on security and justice; it is also unstable. Things can—and might well—get worse unless the United States and other outside actors couple a realistic view of the present with a serious effort to push for a more promising future. But for the present, they should stop banging their heads against the obstacles to an immediate and comprehensive solution of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. Instead, it is time for Plan B.”


  • This commentary is reprinted with permission from  Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

  • Posted in Palestine , Human Rights  
    Add Comment Send to Friend Print
    Related Articles
    Palestinian children’s health in decline, says report
    Tight Security Siege on Palestinian-Egyptian Borders
    Palestinian factions in Cairo identify duties of committees
    Palestinian factions in Cairo agree to new PA unity government
    Habib: MB With Inter-Palestinian Dialogue, Resistance Must Be Preserved
    Seventh Palestinians in Europe conference to be held in Italy soon
    Hamas: All options are open for the Palestinian people to defend the Aqsa Mosque
    Haneyya gov’t deplores IOA intent to demolish 88 Palestinian homes in J’lem
    IOA escalates judaization of holy city, plans demolition of 88 Palestinian homes
    Ministry of prisoners deplores escalating deportation of Palestinian detainees
    A letter from a Palestinian Child to the US President
    Turkey and the Palestinian Question
    IOA confiscates 1700 dunums of Palestinian lands
    Morsi: Palestine Witnesses Deaths, Exchange of Role among Murderers and Usurpers
    A Wounded Palestinian: We Couldn’t Complete our Medical Treatment, Some of us were Tortured
    Mishaal welcomes any initiative to support the Palestinian cause
    How did the Gaza war affect Palestinian public opinion?
    MB MP Slams Egyptian Probes With Palestinian War-Wounded
    Report: Obama will deal with the Palestinian cause in the interest of Israel
    IOA demolish four Palestinian homes in Jerusalem
    Mishaal: We’ll build national authority for the Palestinians at home and abroad
    Haniyyah Calls On Obama to Back Palestinians’ Right to Liberty and Independence
    Israeli poll: Killing Palestinians shortest way to winning elections
    Egypt’s intelligence blackmails wounded Palestinians to tell about Hamas
    Palestinian communities in Europe slam Maleki for criticizing the resistance
    Palestinian-American Recounts How Israel Killed his 11-year-old Son in Gaza
    Israel kills more than 925 Palestinians during its 16-day aggression on Gaza
    Victims of Israeli aggression on Gaza rise to more than 776 Palestinians
    Victims of Israeli aggression on Gaza rise to more than 776 Palestinians
    Egyptian National Forces: We Support Palestinians’ Right To Armed Struggle
    660 Palestinians killed and 2950 wounded in the Gaza holocaust, 135 Palestinians massacred on Tuesda
    Continued Israeli military raids on Gaza kill more than 530 Palestinians
    441 Palestinians including over 70 children killed by Israel since last Saturday
    Ten Palestinians, including prominent Hamas leader, killed in latest massacre
    Two Poems for the Beloved People of Gaza and Occupied Palestine
    Naim: Israeli air strikes on Gaza kill 300 Palestinians, wound 1000 others
    Hamas: Ban Ki-moon remarks on Palestinian missiles biased
    At least 155 Palestinians killed and 200 wounded in Israeli occupation successive and intensive air
    Barhoum: Livni used the Egyptian arena to declare war on Palestinian people
    IOF troops round up 14 Palestinians in a single village