Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Activites
Obama starts well with Muslims but must do more
Obama starts well with Muslims but must do more
He has to follow up with real engagement
Perceptions are a critical piece of the foreign policy matrix. From the perception of the Islamic world, the Obama administration is ticking off many of the right boxes
Monday, March 16,2009 03:58
by Lawrence Pintak*, The Christian Science Monitor

Perceptions are a critical piece of the foreign policy matrix. From the perception of the Islamic world, the Obama administration is ticking off many of the right boxes.

First, President Obama signaled his intention to make a major foreign-policy speech in an Islamic capital during his first 100 days in office (details haven"t been announced yet). Then one of his first sit-down interviews was with the Arab channel Al Arabiya, in which he talked about his Muslim heritage. Secretary of State Clinton recently visited Indonesia, the world"s most populous Muslim country. And now Mr. Obama has chosen Turkey as a key stop on his first presidential foray overseas.

But despite the initial euphoria about the Obama win, cynicism among the world"s Muslims still runs deep, particularly here in the Arab world.

Turkey is – quite literally – a bridge between East and West. Istanbul, its cultural capital, straddles the border between Europe and Asia. So, too, its politics. After rocky relations with the Bush administration, Turkey has recently been playing a mediating role between the US and Syria, and will probably do the same with Iran. A vibrant democracy, it offers a model for cooperation in the religious-secular divide of the Islamic world.

A few years ago, I accompanied a group of CEOs from multinational media conglomerates on a visit to Turkey led by Henry Kissinger. Alcohol is banned in Islam. Yet at a gala dinner at his home, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, leader of the Islamist Justice and Development party, sat with his wife, whose head scarf is a controversial symbol of political Islam in Turkey, as waiters poured wine for the guests. Afterward, there was cognac. It was a vivid sign of this Islamist leader"s non-dogmatic approach.

By visiting Prime Minister Erdogan, Obama is overtly reaching out to what Americans would call "moderate" Islamists. Going to non-Arab Turkey also appears to be an effort to separate US relations with Muslim countries from US policy toward the Arab world. The need for that is evident in a recent University of Maryland poll.

Half of all Indonesians and about 80 percent of Egyptians and Turks believe the goal of US policy is to expand Israel"s borders. Few buy US claims that it supports a Palestinian state.

With Pakistan on the brink of collapse, Afghanistan soaking up American troops, and a plethora of challenges in the Muslim former Soviet republics, the US needs to find new issues of common cause with would-be allies – or at least intermediaries – in the Islamic world that surmount, or at least distract from, anger at US Middle East policy.

That is not helped by the perception that US policy toward Israel continues to be dictated by domestic US politics. Mrs. Clinton is the poster child for that.

Earlier this month, newspapers here in Cairo carried front-page photographs of Clinton being kissed by Israeli President Shimon Peres during her visit to Jerusalem. Arabs saw in that a clear message. Ditto what she said – and did not say – about Gaza, Israeli settlements, Hamas, and human rights in Egypt. Many Arabs fear it"s Condoleezza Rice redux. The Israel lobby"s success in torpedoing Obama"s nominee for head of the National Intelligence Council – widely reported here – underlines the perception of business as usual.

Word on the Middle East diplomatic circuit is that the Clintonites at State are even backing off all that talk of Arab political change. Bush, it seems, gave democracy a bad name. Good news for Arab autocrats, bad news for pro-democracy activists who are already muttering about more American hypocrisy.

Arabs are still willing to be convinced about Obama"s motives. The flurry of diplomatic activity and indications that the administration is willing to talk directly with Tehran and even with the Taliban are being praised on the region"s editorial pages. Arabs welcome the fact that the myopia of the past eight years has been jettisoned in favor of a nuanced approach that recognizes the interconnectedness of the many complex policy challenges of the Middle East.

But to be effective, the Obama administration must talk to all the players, not just those approved by Israeli or Arab regimes. If we"re willing to flirt with the Taliban, why wouldn"t we sit down with Hamas or the Muslim Brotherhood? There is no peace without Hamas and Egypt may have no future without the Brotherhood.

Obama has the symbolism of outreach to the world"s Muslims down pat, but gestures are cheap in a region where lives are readily sacrificed in symbolic acts of martyrdom. Now he must follow up with real, concrete engagement.

That should involve a serious partnership with democratically elected Muslim governments in places like Turkey, Indonesia, and Malaysia. These are countries that will not march in lock step with American policy, but that is precisely what makes them so valuable as allies.

*Lawrence Pintak is director of the Kamal Adham Center for Journalism Training and Research at The American University in Cairo. His latest book is "Reflections in a Bloodshot Lens: America, Islam & the War of Ideas."


Posted in Activites , Human Rights , Islamic Movements , Palestine , Obama  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Obama’s No Socialist. I Should Know.
Mr. Obama: Don’t let Israel destroy America
Obama backs off on Israel, again
Open Letter to President Obama about Democracy Promotion in the Middle East and the Muslim World
Memo to Obama: don’t abandon Arab democrats
Expert: Obama’s Administration Prioritises settlement of Arab-Israeli Conflict
Bi-Partisan Group of Prominent Scholars and Experts Urge President Obama to Make Democracy
Iraqi MB: Obama’s Decision to Withdraw a Step in the Right Direction
Take Action on President Obama’s FY2010 Budget Request for Military Aid to Israel
Obama: faith should unite, not divide
Pointers for the Obama Administration in the Middle East: Avoiding Myths and Vain Hopes
Welcome to Obama’s “New Era of Peace”
Why the Muslim World Can’t Hear Obama ?
Report: Obama will deal with the Palestinian cause in the interest of Israel
Thoughts on Obama’s Outreach to the Arab World
Obama allows CIA kidnappings worldwide as first job
Questions for Barack Obama
Obama moves swiftly on Middle East
Obama’s Middle East challenge
Reactions to Obama’s Al Arabiya Interview
Why Did Obama Choose Al-Arabiya for His First Major Interview?
Haniyyah Calls On Obama to Back Palestinians’ Right to Liberty and Independence
Transcript of Obama’s Interview On Al-Arabiya Television
Obama: Regime Rotation
Resilient Arab regimes deaf to Obama’s words
Question for Barack Obama on Middle East Envoys: How come there ain’t no brothers on the wall?
In Case You Missed It, Obama’s Speech at AIPAC
POMED Asks: “As President, What Should Obama Say to the Middle East?”
Editorial: Not In Defense of Obama
Obama’s Palestine choices
Obama, Middle East and the Freedom Agenda
Obama’s win promotes democracy in Arab world
On Obama’s Inherited Freedom Agenda
Obama could change dynamics in the Arab world
Obama’s Essential Reading
MB Did Not Flatter Obama, It Praised A Value, Says MB Secretary General
Muslim Brotherhood Chairman Comments on Obama’s Victory
Qaradawi: I Supported Obama For Change
Obama One More Time
A Historic Opportunity for President-Elect Obama