Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Activites
Stacher on the Brothers and the Wars
Stacher on the Brothers and the Wars
Friend of the blog and academic Joshua Stacher, who focuses on authoritarianism, Islamist movements and other fun things (and thus knows a lot about Egypt’s ruling National Democratic Party and the Muslim Brothers) has a new piece out in Middle East Report. It’s about the Brothers’ behavior during the Gaza war, and more widely the diverse theories about the divisions that may or may not exist within the group. He argues that the havioc wrought on the region by the Bush administration,
Sunday, March 22,2009 03:51
Arabist

Friend of the blog and academic Joshua Stacher, who focuses on authoritarianism, Islamist movements and other fun things (and thus knows a lot about Egypt’s ruling National Democratic Party and the Muslim Brothers) has a new piece out in Middle East Report. It’s about the Brothers’ behavior during the Gaza war, and more widely the diverse theories about the divisions that may or may not exist within the group. He argues that the havioc wrought on the region by the Bush administration, and its encouragement of Israeli adventurism such as Operation Cast Lead, has weakened the credibility of "pragmatists" among the Brothers who sought a less confrontational approach with the West than is the usual staple of the movement, which after all was founded as an anti-colonial project:

The Gaza war was an enabler of the anti-engagement trend among the Brothers. It bolstered the credibility of the group’s more conservative leaders when they lobby the base that the pragmatic wing’s participatory spirit has led the Brothers to a dead end, where they are just as powerless to affect Egyptian foreign policy as they were when underground. Instead of contesting the regime in the widest domain possible, the conservatives argue that the Brothers should prioritize peaceful "resistance" to the US-Israeli military order, in solidarity with those who have taken up arms against it.

He also criticizes the generational approach to explaining rifts among the Brothers, taking to task Egyptian analyst Khalil al-Anani who developed in his book "The Muslim Brothers: Gerontocracy Racing Against Time" (loose translation of the Arabic al-Ikhwan al-Muslimun: Shukhukha Tussari3 al-Zaman) a theory of four generations fighting it out. (Personally I think al-Anani deserves more credit - his view is more nuanced than this.)

Instead, Josh says a division according to political orientation, notably pragamatist politicians vs. conservative ideologues, may be more useful. I like his take on the General Guide being a CEO rather than an eminence grise and emphasis on consensus that has kept the group together. He also looks at another rift, that of "peasants vs. city slickers" that helps explain different attitudes and the conservative bent of the mostly Delta-based bulk of the movement, as well as possible class explanations for the divisions, since many of the leaders are after all middle-class professionals.

I have differences with Josh over his analysis - for instance, it’s not clear to me that Essam al-Erian is perennially losing entry into the Guidance Council because he is too "moderate" rather than because he has annoyed many with his dilettantism and frequent media appearances claiming to represent the MB on controversial issues. But this piece shows how complex a movement the Egyptian Muslim Brothers are, and that no single framework of analysis is in itself convincing: the MB is a big tent no less diverse than, say, the Republican Party (and no less likely to shift ideologically over time, as the Republicans have from the party of Lincoln into the current morass). Most importantly, it is another important reminder of the crucial importance regional developments can have in the internal developments of political movements and the role they play within their societies. In this turbulent Middle East of ours, it is good to be reminded that things change - sometimes very fast.

The Source


Posted in Activites , Human Rights , Palestine , Islamic Movements  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Egypt releases Internet activist, detains 15 Muslim Brotherhoods
Security Police Arrest 17 Muslim Brotherhood Leaders
Muslim Brotherhood Reform
Iran and the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt?
The Muslim Brotherhood Calls for Pro-Gaza Protest Friday
Muslim Brotherhood Chairman Calls for Confronting Possible Zionist Aggression on Gaza
Egypt`s Muslim Brotherhood thanks Turkey’s Erdogan
Al-Raya Interview With Muslim Brotherhood Deputy Chairman Over Gaza Crisis
Syrian Muslim Brotherhood demands Turkish mediation
Muslim Brotherhood Statement on Sharm El-Sheikh Summit
Muslim Brotherhood Welcomes Qatar’s Call For Summit, Slams Countries That Rejected It
150 Muslim Brotherhood Members Arrested In One Day Over Gaza Protests
Muslim Brotherhood Chairman Denounces Raising Shoes In Parliament
Muslim Brotherhood Calls for Impeaching Israeli Leaders Over Gaza War Crimes
21 Muslim Brotherhood Leaders Arrested In Alexandria After Massive Gaza Demos
Muslim Brotherhood Statement on Egyptian Gaza Initiative
Muslim Brotherhood Launches IkhwanTube In Response To YouTube’s Removal Of Israeli Assaults
Detention of 309 Muslim Brotherhood Leaders, Members Over Gaza Demos
Muslim Brotherhood Demands Egyptian Regime Take Positive Measures for Gaza
Security Police Arrest 20 Muslim Brotherhood Leaders Over Gaza Protests
Muslim Brotherhood Demands Egyptian Regime Take Positive Measures for Gaza
Muslim Brotherhood calls on Muslims all over Egypt to offer a funeral prayer in absentia for martyrs
Egypt Police Arrest 45 Muslim Brotherhood Pro-Gaza Demonstrators, Bans Rally
Egypt State Security Arrests Seven Muslim Brotherhood Members Over Gaza Relief
Muslim Brotherhood Condemns Terrorist Attacks on Gaza, Blames Arab Regimes
Muslim Brotherhood Wishes Christians Merry Christmas
Egypt Police Arrest 27 Muslim Brotherhood Members, Detain MB Relief Activist
Egypt Police Arrest 117 Muslim Brotherhood Members in Two Weeks
Muslim Brotherhood Websites
Muslim Brotherhood Is Considering National Coalition That Would Bypass Mistakes of the Past: Habib
Tunisia Muslim Brotherhood Condemns Arresting Former Leader
Dozens Muslim Brotherhood Members Rounded up on Showing Solidarity with Israeli-Blockaded Gaza
Egypt Police Arrest 64 Muslim Brotherhood Members For Their Solidarity With Gaza
Muslim Brotherhood MPs to Spot-Check Police Stations in Cairo, Alexandria
Court Adjourns Ruling in Favor of Jailed Muslim Brotherhood Leaders
Muslim Brotherhood MPs Condemn Secret U.S. Visit to Egypt Borders
Morsi Slams Escalation Against Muslim Brotherhood Across Egypt
Crackdown on Muslim Brotherhood Students Continues
Interview with Muslim Brotherhood Chairman Mohamed Mahdy Akef
13 Damanhour Muslim Brotherhood Figures Arrested