Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Opinions > Other Opinions
MB and the Question of Inherited Succession
MB and the Question of Inherited Succession
According to Allison, Obama isn’t moving in a vacuum but rather within a system controlling all institutions possessing organized forces. Therefore, he doesn’t look at forces whose relative weights don’t encourage him to venture in with his system. Probably, the only organized force enjoying unmatched wide and popular support in Egypt is the Sufist force comprising of 15 million Egyptians who owe obedience to it. This may explain America’s unprecedented concern with Sufis in Egypt.
Tuesday, May 12,2009 21:59
by Mahmoud Sultan Al-Mesryoon
There are no documented statistics on the exact size of the MB in Egypt.  Some estimate the number of its members to be around 2 million as opposed to 15 million following different Sufi paths.  The MB, however, say that their size doesn’t exceed 20% of the Egyptian voting force. 
 
I believe, actually, that the MB isn’t exaggerating in its estimation of its political size and popular weight as the statements issued by its leadership on this matter are pretty moderate and reasonable.  The question about the weight of the MB is one of great merit rather than triviality, and probably the movement is aware of the real meaning behind it.  Probably the first of these merits, which such questions target, is the question of “inherited succession” and the MB’s position on it.  Moreover, the word “position” is not sufficient to shed light on the details of the practices actually implied by the word as some believe that the movement has the ability to “prevent” this inherited succession, which is an exaggerated belief. 
 
I was impressed with Dr. Mohamed Habib’s reply to a question on this matter, in a symposium held by El-Shuruq moderated by our fellow Diaa Rashwan, when Habib said that there was a difference between “opposing” inherited succession and “preventing” it.  It was clear by the response of the MB’s second man that they the movement was just like any other Egyptian political force having no option other than “refusal” and that they are unable to “prevent” anything unless backed by widespread mass support.
 
The movement alone, therefore, will not do anything, and the problem is in whoever requests the MB to prevent inherited succession as it is in those who call on Obama to bet on Egyptian political forces rather than the Egyptian regime.
 
In the Center for the Study of Islam and Democracy’s annual conference recently held in Washington, the Muslim representative in the American Congress, Keith Allison, said that Obama, like any other politician, will not respond except to the party which possesses an organized force practicing pressure on him.
 
According to Allison, Obama isn’t moving in a vacuum but rather within a system controlling all institutions possessing organized forces.  Therefore, he doesn’t look at forces whose relative weights don’t encourage him to venture in with his system.  Probably, the only organized force enjoying unmatched wide and popular support in Egypt is the Sufist force comprising of 15 million Egyptians who owe obedience to it.  This may explain America’s unprecedented concern with Sufis in Egypt.
 
As for the MB in Egypt and confrontation of the inherited succession scenario, America doesn’t see in the Egyptian political opposition parties but a political vacuum which doesn’t encourage it to venture much with confronting the state via these parties which enjoy neither political nor popular weight that would represent some form of a credit line to protect the MB on the one hand and guarantee the achievement of hindering inherited succession on the other hand.  So, the final benefit from the current situation of Egypt would be zero which allows the Egyptian regime to go on in its scenario of passing down power the way it pleases without incurring any high costs for its action.
 
This is the most suitable explanation of the true number and sizes of forces in Egypt.  Therefore, bearing the MB the sole responsibility of “confronting inherited succession” will be, no doubt, an unjust request lacking in objectivity and further useless agitation of the movement.

Posted in Other Opinions , MB in Arabian press  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Egypt’s Gamal Mubarak Aims to Underpin Growth
Habib: Yesterday’s Arrests Linked With Gamal Mubarak’s visit to U.S.
Gamal Mubarak Visits DC
Expert: Hidden Aim behind Gamal Mubarak’s Visit to DC
Gamal Mubarak: "We Need Audacious Leaders"
Brotherhood’s Supreme Guide denies supporting Gamal Mubarak for president
IOA bars Pope’s representative from visiting Gaza for Sunday services
Shares Scheme Is Propaganda for Gamal Mubarak, Says Economic Expert
Gamal Mubarak’s Tours Usher In Succession, Says MP
Gamal Mubarak’s Tours Usher In Succession, Says MP
Amr Hamzawi : Gamal Mubarak lacks legitimacy
After Gaddafi, Egypt Opposition Wants Gamal Mubarak To Follow Suit
Mahdi Akef: Muslim Brotherhood Rejects Gamal Mubarak as President
MPs Furious Over Pope Shenouda Mistreatment at Heathrow Airport
Pastor Manuel and PCAS Chairman call for Pope Benedict XVI to end siege
Pope’s deputy : We do not Fear the Muslim Brotherhood’s Rise
Gamal Mubarak: No Deals between the MB and NDP
MB Denies Mediation With Gamal Mubarak & Rejects Power Succession
Pope Shenouda Urges Muslim "Lobby" in The West
Akef congratulates Pope Shenouda for the Coptic Easter Holiday
Gamal Mubarak Denies Egypt Reneging on Reform
Egypt: The Gamal Mubarak Paradox
Legal society asks Pope Benedict to seek release of Palestinian prisoners
IN RESPONSE TO HERALD SUN’s PULBLICATION titled POPE LASHES EVIL OF JIHAD
MB Chairman Condemns Pope’s Statements
Islamic leaders denounce Pope’s remarks
Ghanoushi Demands Pope To Apologize To Muslims
Pope Seen Criticizing Islam
The Pope speech at the Vatican website
Muslims Insist on Pope’s Apology
Pope and Dialogue with Islam
PSL condemns statements of Pope Benedict XVI
PA foreign ministry condemns Pope’s blasphemous statement on Islam as anger engulfs Palestinians
Coptic Figures Say Pope’s Statements Sow Seeds Of Sedition
Your Comments: Pope’s Statements
Pope tells Muslims he is "deeply sorry"
Were the Pope’s words Questions or Accusations?
Sunnis And Shiites Condemn The Pope’s Remarks
Gamal Mubarak Speaks of Egypt’s Right To Nuclear Energy
Doctrinal Ideological Roots of Pope’s Attitude towards Islam
Muhammad’s sword, Pope Benedict XVI in the service of George W. Bush
The Pope and Islam : The True Debate
Not his first time to attack Islam, Was The Pope calling for a New Crusade?
Hala Mustafa: My Clash with Security Apparatus, not Gamal Mubarak
Heikal on Gamal Mubarak
Gamal Mubarak Faints During NDP General Secretariat Meeting
Brother Gamal Mubarak
Coptic Intellectuals Reject Pope Benedict’s New Document
Gamal Mubarak’s Call For Dialogue Met With Skepticism
Who Will Succeed Pope Shenouda?
Gamal Mubarak launches ruling party’s Battle of Cairo
Gamal Mubarak: Egypt’s Next President?