Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Human Rights
Gaza: pursuit of the laws of war
Gaza: pursuit of the laws of war
If the UN fails to further investigate crimes committed during the conflict it will ensure stalemate, and more suffering for civilians
The Israeli government and its supporters have lashed out at the report of the UN board of inquiry into Israeli attacks on UN installations during Israel’s latest offensive in Gaza. The report, they say, is biased, tendentious and inaccurate.
Thursday, May 14,2009 06:01
by Tom Porteous Guardian

The Israeli government and its supporters have lashed out at the report of the UN board of inquiry into Israeli attacks on UN installations during Israel"s latest offensive in Gaza. The report, they say, is biased, tendentious and inaccurate. According to Robbie Sabel, writing in Comment is Free, the "unbalanced report" does "little to bring understanding or justice to the conflict in Gaza".

The full report has not been published, but there"s little in the summary that UN secretary general Ban Ki-moon sent to the security council on Tuesday to support such claims. On the contrary, it provides careful but compelling evidence that Israeli Defence Forces (IDF) violated the laws of war during their military operations around UN installations in Gaza.

According to the summary, the board of inquiry concluded that "IDF actions involved varying degrees of negligence and recklessness with regard to United Nations premises and the safety of United Nations staff and other civilians within those premises, with consequent deaths, injuries and extensive physical damage and loss of property". The board also holds "Hamas or another Palestinian actor" responsible for one attack on a UN installation – a World Food Progamme warehouse hit by a Qassam rocket.

The terms of reference of the UN inquiry were extremely narrow. Its job was to look at attacks on eight UN installations and one UN convoy during the period of Israel"s military offensive. As far as one can tell from the summary, the board has been meticulous in sticking to these terms of reference.

However, the conclusions of the inquiry, as represented in the summary (which, it should be noted, was not written by those who wrote the full report), raise broader questions about the use of force by the IDF during the conflict. It appears the authors of the UN report felt these questions should not be ducked. The summary notes that the board of inquiry was "deeply conscious" that the attacks on UN installations investigated in its report "are among many incidents ­during Operation Cast Lead involving civilian victims".

The board therefore recommended that "these incidents should be investigated as part of an impartial inquiry, mandated and adequately resourced, to investigate violations of international humanitarian law in Gaza and southern Israel by the IDF and by Hamas and other Palestinian militants".

But in his letter to the security council presenting his summary, secretary general Ban Ki-moon says bluntly: "I do not plan any further inquiry." Whether under pressure from external sources – as reported in the Israeli media – or not, the secretary general has thus rejected his own board of inquiry"s most important recommendation even before the security council has had time to discuss it.

Indeed Ban could not even bring himself to put his weight behind an inquiry that has already been mandated by the UN human rights council to investigate broader laws of war violations in the Gaza fighting. Although the human rights council has often been criticised for an anti-Israel bias, this inquiry is headed by Richard Goldstone, who gained international respect for his critical role in dismantling apartheid in his native South Africa and served with distinction as the chief prosecutor at the international criminal tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda. Goldstone has said that he will look at violations committed by both sides in the conflict.

So what happens now? The media and human rights organisations like Human Rights Watch have already documented serious violations of the laws of war by both sides in the conflict in Gaza, several of which have now been corroborated by this latest UN report. There is a strong prima facie case for a broad international and impartial inquiry, as recommended by the UN board.

Justice Goldstone"s inquiry (which has been accepted by Hamas but rejected by Israel) should be fully backed by the secretary general, the security council and all those states who profess to care about the vital importance of upholding the rule of law in international affairs.

There is a wide perception, backed up by strong evidence, that serious laws of war violations were committed in Gaza during Operation Cast Lead. Failure by the UN to investigate and make recommendations for the prosecution of individuals responsible for war crimes will perpetuate the climate of impunity that characterises this conflict, like so many others, and ensure that in the next round of fighting once again it will be civilians who suffer most. That will only further polarise and radicalise both sides and dim even further the prospects of peace between Israelis and Palestinians

The Source


Posted in Human Rights , Palestine  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Egyptian Authority Prevented A European Convoy From Entering Gaza
Palestinian activist Habib to hold hearing on Gaza in European parliament
Erdogan calls for opening Gaza crossings to start rebuilding efforts
UN experts plan to probe war crimes committed by Israel in Gaza
’Tell Her’: a Play for Gaza
European campaign criticizes world slackness in dealing with Gaza siege
Gov’t against siege urges Egypt to facilitate entry of Hope convoy into Gaza
UNICEF: Gaza children continue to suffer physically and psychologically
Khudari appeals to world’s labor unions to support Gaza workers
Scottish delegation decides to bring more convoys to break siege on Gaza
Convoy Update: Ambulances and Medical Aids to Gaza
Israel/Gaza: Israeli Military Investigation Not Credible
Preparations for "Hope" convoy to Gaza accelerating
Anti-siege gov’t committee: The world to blame for mass killing of Gaza patients
ACHR: Gaza Probe Mission Does its Job
European figures including Swiss MP to participate in Italian aid convoy to Gaza
Gov’t committee calls on Arab foreign ministers to work on ending Gaza suffering
Galloway to lead new aid convoy to Gaza
European campaign makes urgent appeal for saving impoverished Gaza people
Arab League charges Israel with trying to conceal its crimes in Gaza
EMHRN Delegation Denied Permit To Enter Gaza
Children the Biggest Victims of the War on Gaza (Report)
EU: We are not happy with Israeli practices in Jerusalem, Gaza
Gaza’s phosphorus legacy
France calls Gaza ’open-air prison’
24 MB Students Expelled, 26 Others Transferred To Investigation for Gaza Events
Israel accused of indiscriminate phosphorus use in Gaza
Human rights watch accuses Israel of committing war crimes during war on Gaza
Falk to submit to UN human rights council report on Israel’s war crimes in Gaza
European campaign condemns IOF troops’ practices at Gaza borders
Israeli Soldier Says Military Rabbis Framed Gaza Mission as Religious
Israel’s Dirty Secrets in Gaza
UN Envoy: Gaza Op Seems to be War Crime of Greatest Magnitude
International galaxy calls for probe into war crimes in Gaza