Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Political Islam Studies
Should the Burqa be Banned?
Should the Burqa be Banned?
The issue of the burqa (or the niqab) is one that I’ve struggled with because it forces us to choose between competing goods. It cuts to fundamental questions of the limits of tolerance and free speech. Mona Eltahawy is a courageous advocate for women’s equality and I enjoy her columns a great deal, but I find her most recent piece for the New York Times somewhat perplexity.
Thursday, July 2,2009 17:37
by Shadi Hamid Democracy Arsenal

The issue of the burqa (or the niqab) is one that I"ve struggled with because it forces us to choose between competing goods. It cuts to fundamental questions of the limits of tolerance and free speech. Mona Eltahawy is a courageous advocate for women"s equality and I enjoy her columns a great deal, but I find her most recent piece for the New York Times somewhat perplexity. She advocates a burqa ban because the burqa violates women"s rights. I agree with almost everything she says regarding the burqa, that it, in effect, "erases women from society." Agreed. As an American-Muslim, it both bothers and offends me to see women in major American cities with only their eyes showing. The niqab is an affront to the values I grew up with, but, then again, so are so many other things. I do not enjoy the right to not be offended.

Eltahawy also references Soad Saleh, an Islamic law professor who says that the burqa has "nothing to do with Islam" and is, rather, a cultural tradition. Again, I fully agree.

French President Nicholas Sarkozy said recently, "The burqa is not a religious sign, it is a sign of the subjugation, of the submission of women. I want to say solemnly that it will not be welcome on our territory.” Again, I agree with the first sentence but I"m not sure how the second sentence follows from the first. You cannot justify a ban on something simply by saying that it is a sign of the submission of women. There have to be legal and/or constitutional grounds for implementing such a ban, and, in this case, such grounds do not appear to exist. You could presumably institute or execute laws that prevent men from forcing their wives to do things against their will, but if the burqa is something some women choose to do voluntarily then such injunctions would not be germane.

What is interesting, and rather puzzling, about Eltahawy"s article is that it does not attempt to make any real argument for banning the burqa, even though is presumably the intent of her piece. The idea that we can or should ban things we don"t agree with is dangerous because it can easily be applied - as it often is - in reverse situations. For example, there have been attempts in Muslim-majority countries to silence minority opinions on the exact same grounds - that a form of expression must be banned because it is an affront to a certain set of norms and values that the majority holds dear.

On such grounds, anything that hints of criticism of Islam in Muslim-majority countries, even those that are supposedly secular, can be made punishable by law. Scholars and commentators have been charged with apostasy and, in some extreme cases, forced into exile for supposedly undermining the Islamic faith (see for instance the case of Nasr Hamed Abu Zayd). The reasoning here operates in parallel to Eltahawy"s: Voluntary expressions of speech or faith must be restricted because they come into conflict with societal perceptions of what is "right." It sets a dangerous precedent, then, to go down this path, whether in the name of one set of ideals or another - even if we are convinced, as may very well be, that the one set of ideals is better than the other.

That said, I am more than willing to be convinced that there are indeed reasonable legal and constitutional grounds for banning the niqab, but I have trouble seeing how those might take precedence over the higher principle and constitutionally-guaranteed right to free speech and expression.

The Source


Posted in Political Islam Studies , Activites , Human Rights  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Habib:allocating seats to women in the People’s Assembly (PA) is unconstitutional
Egyptian women divided on parliamentary quota - Feature
Egyptian women divided on parliamentary quota - Feature
Supporting Palestinian Resistance and Women’s Political Participation Are Our Causes
Hamas: We retain the right to retaliate to PA violations against W. Bank women
Katatni: Our stance From Women is Clear And No One Can Outbid Us
Families of women imprisoned by Abbas’s militia appeal for help
What Do Muslim Women Want?
The Role of Foreign Policy and Women in Iran’s Elections
Kuwaiti Elections: Advancement for Women, Retreat for Islamists
EGYPT: Thanks to Facebook, Young Women Take to Political Activism
A study on the situation of women, children and the Egyptian village
Egyptian Security Assault El-Behera Pro-Gaza Protest, 32 Women Injured
Legal center: 55 children, 9 women among victims of the IOF Gaza massacre
New Role for Women in the UAE
Islamists’ Rise Could Benefit Women’s Rights
Ministry of prisoners: Israel is responsible for kidnapping four women from Gaza
Police Officers Belittle Women’s Issues
Press Release: Women in Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood Pushing for Change
Women in Gaza rally at Rafah border crossing to protest its closure
In the Shadow of the Brothers: The Women of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood
Women of the Brotherhood
Egypt: The Muslim Brotherhood on Women’s Rights
Scores of Women Denied Travelling and Joining their Families
Digital democracy: women activists making IT their own
After Her Release: MP Mansour Unveils Women’s Suffering in Israeli Jails
MP Saleh narrates heart breaking stories about women in Israeli jails
The Muslim Brotherhood is Pro-Dialogue, Engagement of Women and Copts : Habib
MP Accuses Government of Discriminating Against Women
Ex-detainee: Palestinian women are living in tragic conditions in Israeli jails
Bush lectures Arab world on political reform, women’s rights
Habib: Egyptian Regime Blocks MB Attempts to Field Women in Municipal Elections
GENDER ISSUES - WOMEN IN ISLAM - article collection
On International Women’s Day, Palestinian women continue their struggle
QUR’AN, HADITH AND WOMEN
Unveiled: the Israeli women in ‘burkas’
In Recognition of Women
MB Chairman: Aggression on Gaza Women March ’a Criminal Act’
Egyptian Police Attacks Gazan Women Demonstrating in Rafah
Reviving a Tradition: Muslim Women as Religious Authorities