Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > MB Blogs
Cracking down on moderate Islamists
Cracking down on moderate Islamists
The detention of the three MB bloggers is part of a wider crackdown which has directly targeted the most moderate and pragmatic figures within the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood. That ongoing policy escalated dramatically with the arrest of several members of the MB’s Guidance Council. The arrested figures including Abdel Monem Abou al-Fattouh, a leading moderate and pragmatic figure within the Egyptian MB, on what appear to be trumped up charges related to his alleged activities with t
Friday, July 24,2009 05:12
by Marc Lynch

 learned yesterday that three leading young Muslim Brotherhood bloggers , including AbdelRahman Ayyesh (pictured above), Ahmed Abu Khalil and Magdi Sa"ad, had been arrested at the Cairo airport and then transferred to state security facilities.  Ayyesh and Saad were both important parts of the youth MB bloggers movement which was pushing the organization towards greater internal transparency and more moderate, politically engaged positions within Egyptian politics.  Their detention is deeply troubling... but all too typical of the recent trends in an Egyptian regime consumed by questions about the transition of power from Hosni Mubarak and by its largely failed efforts to broker a Palestinian national unity government. 

 The detention of the three MB bloggers is part of a wider crackdown which has directly targeted the most moderate and pragmatic figures within the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood.  That ongoing policy escalated dramatically with the arrest of several members of the MB"s Guidance Council.  The arrested figures including Abdel Monem Abou al-Fattouh, a leading moderate and pragmatic figure within the Egyptian MB, on what appear to be trumped up charges related to his alleged activities with the Global Muslim Brotherhood Organization (about which I"m planning to write a longer piece soon). Abou el-Fattouh remains in prison, where his health is reportedly deteriorating.


Me and detained MB blogger AbdelRahman Ayyesh in Cairo, October 2007

 This crackdown on the moderate elements of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood almost seems calculated to demoralize reformists and drive the MB towards more radical positions.  Amr Choukbi, a leading Egyptian analyst of Islamist movements, notes today that Abou el-Fattouh -- a true pragmatist and reformist -- faces a difficult position attempting to open up a largely conservative and closed MB organization, which is made even worse by such political crackdowns against the advocates of political moderation. Khalil el-Anani, another leading Egyptian analyst of Islamist movements, wrote an article the other day laying out the potential consequences:

Firstly, the stepped up crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood could increase the polarization within the Egyptian scene, which is already boiling over other many political, economic and social factors.

Secondly, the political and religious isolation of the Muslim Brotherhood could contribute to the emergence of either more superficial or stricter religious discourse.

Thirdly, the increased suppression of the Muslim Brotherhood could force some of the group’s grassroots to turn on their leaders and stage violent protests or call for civil disobedience.

It would be no exaggeration to say that the arrest of the group’s leading reformers, led by Abdel Moneim Aboul Fotouh, is tantamount to the execution of Sayyid Qutb in mid 1960s of the last century and its far-reaching repercussions on the Muslim Brotherhood’s young generation and the other young religious enthusiasts at the time.

It is enough to look at the Muslim Brotherhood discussion boards and blogs to find out the extent of resentment and tension among the Brotherhood grassroots after the arrest of Aboul Fotouh, and their appeals to the group’s leaders to move and to take firm positions against the regime.

Fourth, the arrest of the group’s reformists and moderates could throw the group into intolerance and conservatism. This could benefit the regime temporarily, but it could adversely affect the society on the long run.

Fifth, the isolation of the Muslim Brotherhood could contribute to the emergence of radical religious movements seeking to fill the religious and political gap between the state and the society. 

Is that what the Egyptian government wants?  Does that serve American foreign policy interests?  Or would such interests be better served by the evolution of a more moderate, pragmatic and reformist Muslim Brotherhood participating in the political system? Perhaps such matters would make for a useful topic of conversation during Hosni Mubarak"s reported August visit to Washington DC. 


The Source

Posted in MB Blogs  
Related Articles
Continued Detenion Of Two Bloggers at Cairo airport.
10 Worst Countries to be a Blogger
Indonesia’s election a triumph of pragmatism over ideology, moderate Muslims over radical Islamists
The Dangers of the Iranian Blogosphere
Egypt: A Blogger Disappears After His Release
Police officer assaults, breaks into blogger’s home
UN experts condemn detention of Egyptian blogger
Jordan: Blogger Exposes a State Secret
Egypt violates international law by imprisoning blogger, says UN body
Blogging and social networking dominate conference on Arab media
Egypt must halt campaign against bloggers
Moroccan anti-corruption journalist & blogger arrested Journalist should be questioned not detained
Blogger Adel Started an Open Strike
Endless Escalation Between Egyptian Bloggers, Regime
Freed Egyptian protester describes ordeal, but fate of seized blogger is unknown
Egyptian Bloggers and Journalists in the Hot Seat
Egypt Police Arrest Three Participants in Gaza Relief Convoy, Including Blogger
Communication Accuses Interior Ministry Of Kidnapping Blogger Mohamed Adel
Egypt: one blogger disappeared and another still in custody despite court order
Protest Against Blogger’s Disappearance, Extending Detention of Another
Iran Moderate Sunni Group Says It Still Endorses MB Ideology
Blogger Disappears in Mysterious Circumstances
Fayyoum Prosecution Decides To Release Blogger Khairi
Blogger Mohamed Khairi To Be Referred Tomorrow
Blogger Mohamed Khairi Arrested for the Second Time
What Moderate Islamists Expect from Obama?
Blogger Mamdouh El Monayyar Released After Seven- Month Detention
Bloggers bucking the Brotherhood in Egypt
Za’rour Condemns Exclusion of Student From Hostel For His Blog
Blogger Abdul Tawwab Abducted From Faiyum
ANHRI: Egyptian Internet Bloggers Vulnerable To Arrest & Persecution
An Egyptian woman blogger has received an international prize
Bloggers and the Brotherhood
Sectarian tension: from extremists to moderates
Muslim brotherhood and blogging
Qaradawi: Muslim Brotherhood Represents Moderate Islam, Best Group in Muslim Nation
Core to Commonplace: The evolution of Egypt’s blogosphere
Core to Commonplace: The evolution of Egypt’s blogosphere
Moroccan Appeals Court Acquits Blogger Mohamed Al Rajhi
Brotherhood Blogs: Windows To Revelation, Criticism And Organizational Rise
To Cover Honor Killings in Eygpt, Must Blog Anonymously
In One Session, Without Defense or Lawyers The Sentence of the Moroccan Blogger, Mohamed Elrraji...
The Myth of "The Myth of Moderate Islam"
Join the Revolution! An interview with Antony Loewenstein on The Blogging Revolution
Egypt bloggers take on U.S. elections
The Prosecution of the First Moroccan Blogger
The Role of Moderateness in Political Stability
April 6 Youth Protests to Have a Blogger Released
Family of MB Blogger Demands His Release
Police Assaults A Woman In A Rally Against Blogger Detention
Petition For Prosecutor General To Release Blogger Refaat
The Blogging Revolution lands
The State Security Arrest a Blogger under the State of Emergency Law
Egyptian blogger Mohamed Refaat is released
MP Al-Husseini: Gov’t Still Detains Al-Monayar, MB Blogger
Egypt’s bloggers and labor activists make common cause
New Arrest Warrant against MB Blogger Al-Monayer
EGYPT: Blogger, interpreter tortured by SSI
Port Said Police Arrests the Blogger Tamer Mabrouk
SSP Renews Detention of MB Blogger, Disregards Court Decision
Revisions Add to Islamic Moderation, Interview with Rafiq Habib
MB MP: Blogging is an Outlet for Egypt’s Disaffected Youth
Egyptian Bloggers Condemn "Egyptian Stances" Campaign
Mapping the blogosphere
Doctors Blog against Medical Carelessness
The Other Arab Bloggers
Arab Bloggers Keep Watch Over Government – And Each Other
Anti—NDP bloggers call the MB to deal differently with the regime
Egypt: Torture for Bloggers and Activists
Challenge to Cairo: Is the Muslim Brotherhood a Moderating Influence in Egyptian Politics?
Unfair Sentence Against blogger Tariq Biasi
Blogging the strike: activists remain behind bars
al Jazerra focus on bloggers and Egypt
al Jazerra focus on bloggers and Egypt
Brotherhood blogger prevented from leaving the country
Muslim Brotherhood Blogger Abdel Monem Mahmoud Banned from Traveling to Morocco
Bloggers Call for Coordination Among Opposition for May 4 Strike
In search of...moderate Muslims
The Spell of Islamophobia and Moderate Muslims
Blogger Mamdouh Al-Moniyar Referred to Forensic Medicine After Torture
Bloggers call for "Public Tribunal" for 40 Egyptian Officials
Egypt targets Muslim Brotherhood moderates
Egypt Targets Muslim Brotherhood Moderates
Bloggers Call for Dropping Egypt ’s Ruling NDP in Municipal Elections
Egypt Targets Moderate Muslim Brothers
A Moderate Islamist is Arrested in Egypt - and What it Means for Us
In Search of Moderate Muslims
Let’s not forget the moderate Islamists
Rabbi Pelavin’s Response to “Attention Rabbi Yoffie: Please Speak To Moderate Muslims”
Brotherhood Bloggers: A New Generation Voices Dissent
Moderate Muslims in Southeast Asia organize to show true Islam to the world
Fayyad incites Bush against moderate Fatah leaders
Open Letter to Saudi King to Release the Saudi Blogger”Ahmed Al-Farhan”
Blogging in the Arab World
Blogging and Politics in Jordan
More Arab bloggers in peril
Be the moderate you’re looking for
Funnelling the power of individual blogs
Saudi Authorities Still Detain Blogger Fouad Al Farhan
Another Egyptian Blogger in Jail
Online campaign supports detained blogger
A memo in solidarity with detained blogger Ahmed Mohsen
End of the MB Blogging Spring?
Moderate Islamists and peaceful democracy
YouTube Restores Account of Award-Winning Egyptian Blogger
Al Fayyum MB Blogger, Leaders Detained
Why are Western officials hesitant to talk to moderate Islamists ?
Muslim Brotherhood bloggers
THE EYERANIANS“Moderate” Arab Regimes
Egyptian Bloggers Reject Torture in Own Film Festival
Blogger Karim Amer Tortured in Burj Al-Arab Prison
Looking for Moderate Islamists
A question of moderation
A Neo-con Shows His Moderate Side
Crackdowns On Bloggers Increasing, Survey Finds
Crackdowns On Bloggers Increasing, Survey Finds
Egyptian bloggers expose horror of police torture
One hell of feast for the MB bloggers
Egyptian Bloggers Hold Conference to Defend Freedoms
One hell of feast for the MB bloggers
Egyptian Regime Blocks Opposition Websites, Weblogs
Egyptian bloggers expose horror of police torture
Blogging consequences
The moderate behind bars
Do not undermine moderate Islamists: The case of Muslim Brotherhood leader, Khayrat El-Shater
Web users at internet cafes allegedly under the radar of state security, says blogger
Islamic party courts election victory in moderate Morocco
Scenario of succession ...how Egyptian bloggers regard it
Egyptian blogger Monem threatened again
Blogging for democracy around the world
Arab Bloggers Exercise Democracy and Prompt Debate Despite Tough Opposition From Governments
Inside the belly of the dog, A blog on his birthday for Sasha
Egypt: Award-Winning Blogger Among New Arrests
The Blogger Scene in Egypt
Sharqawi blogs from prison
Sit-In to Be Staged By Bloggers in Solidarity with Nour
Blogs on the Middle East Crisis, When More Than Just Weapons Speak
State Security threatens blogger
2006, year of crackdowns on blogging
Egypt urged to free blogger
Egypt bloggers reveal new torture case
Bloggers, Kifaya and Ikhwanweb Against Torture
Bloggers being watched in the Middle East.
MB blogs: A Step Towards More Freedom of Expression
Free the Egyptian blogger! But...
USA’s favorite Arab nation jails bloggers
Egyptian Blogging on Trial
The blogger and the pharaoh
As a blogger is jailed, promises that the internet would challenge dictators have proved illusory
Blogger on Ice
Brotherhood of The Blog
URGENT: Lawsuit to be filed to block 21 Egyptian blogs
The MB in Egypt is blogging, Where Speech Isn’t Free
Bloggers and Rights Activists Against Torture Meeting
HRW to Mubarak’s regime: Investigate police torture, rape of blogger Sharqawi
Blogging for freedom
Bloggers & New Media [Part I]
Inside the school of the Egyptian blogosphere
Arabisc: Rebelling Bloggers from Syria to Tunisia
Egypt: Bloggers Arrested in Anti-Government Rally
Egypt: Arrested Bloggers Released Following Constitutional Amendment Clashes
The Changing Face of Arab Blogs
Fighting Torture with Mobile Phones and Weblogs
Egypt: Bloggers Among Egyptian Demo Detainees
Middle East bloggers click for change
EGYPT: Egyptian democracy activist blogs from cell
Updated: 3 Egyptian Bloggers Detained
Blogs & Websites Under Threat
WPS: Blogging the New Arab Public
9 Behera MBs Detained, House of MB Blogger Raided
MB Blogger Detained
Security Forces Hunting MB Blogger Abdel Moneim Mahmoud
The Police Broke into a Journalist Blogger’s Residence
Blogger Abdel Monem Mahmoud Has Been Arrested
Blogger Moneim detained
Blogger Abdul Moneim Mahmoud Jailed 15 Days
Bloggers Protest Arrests With Their Keyboards
State security raids home, detains Brotherhood blogger
Arabeyes: Egyptian Blogger Abdul Monem Mahmood Arrested
Rights groups criticize the arrest of an Egyptian blogger
What if they arrested a blogger and nobody cared?
Bloggers may be the real opposition
Egyptian blogger ordered detained for 15 days
HRW Demands Release of MB Blogger Abdel Monem Mahmoud
’Brotherhood’ Blogs In Egypt Offer View Of Young Islamists
Bloggers Celebrate President’s Birthday, Son’s Marriage, Reject Succession
Petition For Release Of Bloggers Kareem Amer And Abdul-Moneim Mahmud
Egypt Blog Rebels Silenced
Frontline Club: Politics and blogging
Jailed MB blogger and journalist among 25 hunger strikers
Ikhwanweb’s Moneim Blogs from Egyptian Prison
Bahrain in transition, from blog to street
Media Honours Blog about Ikhwan
Moderation Despite the RAND Corporation!
Another 15 Days Detention To Blogger Monem
Jailed MB Blogger Monem Mahmoud Visits Critically Ill Father
Blogger of the Brotherhood
The hidden Arab moderates
Muslim Brotherhood Girls, Blogosphere
Al Erian: MB Bloggers’ Criticism To Leaders Healthy Phenomenon
Algeria: Algerian blogger in threat of imprisonment
House Of Egyptian Blogger Raided
Monem: No To Jailing Algerian Blogger Abd El Salam Baroudy
Blogging Against Mubarak
Blogger Detained While Covering Shura Election Day
Update:Blogger Omar el-Sharqawi released
Egypt: Elections Rigging Videos, US Aid Cuts and A New Blog by Talented Movie Director
Egypt: Blogger is Released, Court Case to Block 50 Blogs, Press Attacked By Bloggers and More
Effect of Egyptian Blogs on Politics, Society
Phone threats against bloggers continue…
Egypt: Two Bloggers Arrested
Mixed Baghdad Bloggers on the White House’s Iraq progress report.
Experts: Erdogan’s Win Milestone for Moderate Islamic Movements
Is the Muslim Brotherhood Moderate?
Islamic Weblogs
Clark, Ridley: MB Trial Part of War Against Moderate Islam
Egypt’s blog rebels silenced by jail
Blogger interrogated; released on bail
Monem Was Blogging Freedom
Concerns Grow Over Bloggers Quitting Due To Govt Intimidation
Bloggers, Freedom of Expression
What if they arrested a blogger and nobody cared
Arabeyes: Bahraini Blogger in Court
Call for release of blogger who reports on torture of detainees
Blogs Against Military Rulers
Blogger Alaa Saif: Egyptian Blogosphere Under Siege
3 Egyptian Bloggers Detained
Hosni Mubarak’s regime won’t delete Egypt’s bloggers