Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Other Blogs
The MB in Egypt is blogging, Where Speech Isn’t Free
The MB in Egypt is blogging, Where Speech Isn’t Free
What’s most important is bringing attention to the fact that governments are blocking sites and denying access. The Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt is blogging, and that’ll probably lead to a crackdown. And we need to fight for the rights of these voices and others, even if we disagree with their politics.
Monday, March 12,2007 00:00
by www.andycarvin.com

Blogging Where Speech Isn’t Free

Jon Lebkowsky, moderator
Shava Nerad, TOR
Ethan Zuckerman, Global Voices
Rob Faris, Harvard Berkman Center
Shahed Amanullah, HalalFire Media
Yasmina Tesanovic, Serbian filmmaker


Faris:

The OpenNet Initiative. There was a time when we hoped the net would be a frontier place not subject to natl sovereignty. That idea is pretty much dead. And many countries use that sovereignty to censor or filter the Net. We’ve looked at 40 countries so far, and more than two dozen of them are using filtering. Half are filtering social issues or political content, primarily blogs. Filtering is a messy, incomplete process. It targets certain content, but it’s basically impossible to actually block everything you want to without knocking out stuff that’s not on your hit list. So when Pakistan tried to block certain yahoo hosts, they knocked out 52,000 other websites.

In North Korea, suppression of opposing viewpoints basically shuts down the Net, while China wants to maintain a vibrant internet but still try to block things they find unacceptable. The rules of censorship have changed and continue to evolve. It’s very fluid and ill-defined. That creates both opportunities and dangers.

Zuckerman:

I tend to work on citizen media - blogging, podcasting and the like - particularly in the developing world. We often talk about it in the context of press freedoms. There’s high repression in places like North Korea, Burma, Turkmenistan. In medium oppression stakes like China, Iran and Zimbabwe, citizen media tools are embraced more actively. In places with freer press, like South Africa, they use these tools less because they have other platforms for sharing their ideas. Iran is an amazing case study. In 2004, suddenly you had 60,000 blogs start. The independent press had shut down and many of them moved into the blogosphere. So even the vice president started a blog to have better communication with his constituents.

My org, globalvoicesonline.org, looks at citizens media in the world. Some of it focuses on just cultural activities, but a lot focuses on freedom and politics. In Bahrain, there’s a pdf from google maps showing how much land is controlled by the monarchy, and the size of their palaces compared to where everyone else lives. They blocked Google Maps because of. The Tunisian Prison Map used google maps to show where the secret prisons are, and which dissidents were there. Alaa abd el Fatah blogged on paper while they were in prison, and his wife posted it at www. manalaa.net. We even see video being smuggled out, like Zimbabwe protestors being broken up violently in Harare.

This is all user-generated media, and it’s making states very, very upset. They react in four ways. They block the sites, the tools; register bloggers, even threaten their safety. In Ethiopia, you can’t see a site like nazret.com, the leading opposition site. In Pakistan, blogger.com is blocked, just so they can censor six sites. This lead to dontblocktheblog.com to get around this. (A guy from Blogger in the audience says the block ended last week.)

FreeKareem.com - Egyptian blogger sentenced to four years in prison, and now there’s an active campaign to have him released.

How do we fight back? We can mirror sites, like isaacmao.com and notisaacmao.com. Isaac redirects people to the second site when he’s blocked. There are also anonymous blogs, like sleeplessinsudan.blogspot.com, which was run by a relief worker in Darfur. I maintain a guide on anonymous blogging, and Reporters Without Borders has one as well.

What’s most important is bringing attention to the fact that governments are blocking sites and denying access. The Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt is blogging, and that’ll probably lead to a crackdown. And we need to fight for the rights of these voices and others, even if we disagree with their politics.

Shava Nerad: TOR allows people to circumvent firewalls and go online anonymously. We have around 1,000 proxy servers around the world. When you connect, you get randomly routed through a trail of these servers, making it impossible for authorities to see where you came from. So you can blog without authorities knowing which cybercafe your at, for example. When you blog, you normally leave a trail that shows your physical location. If you’re saying risky things, that makes you vulnerable. So you need to wipe the footprints off of that trail to keep you safe.

We talk a lot about free speech as if it were an absolute good we need immediately. It’s a good idea, but a lot of my family comes from parts of the world where free speech isn’t a reality. There are ways to protect yourself - they’re safety valves. Medium suppression countries realize that free speech is inevitable in a Darwinian sort of way, but they want to control the pace of change. China doesn’t shut down all free speech but they try to throttle it so they control the message. So it’s not as monolithic as it seems. It’s process. When I see people in the US blogging about it, they don’t always see it as a live action roleplaying game involving internet diplomacy. It’s an ongoing story of cultural tensions. People need the tools to do this, but here in the US, we need to understand that there’s a process going on, and in our activism, we should recognize that rather than just vilifying the other side.

Amanullah:

I run altmuslim.com and HalalFire Media, trying to cultivate the Islamic blogosphere. A lot of online repression happens in Muslim countries. Why is that the case? You have political instability, undemocratic regimes and the rise of extremism, because Islam is in flux. Why should we care about that? The Muslim world deserves political and press freedoms just like everybody else; they shouldn’t be written off as backwards and hopeless. There’s a need for free expression to create an Islam that’s in sync with modernity. We all have a stake in that battle. Sept 11 reminds us that we just can’t "contain" them. We need to support Islamic bloggers who are trying to help countries go through this change.

Even when governments aren’t legitimate, they wrap themselves in a clock of religious responsibility. There are also extremists trying to drive a political or moral agenda. It’s tough to run a bookstore that’s open without getting flak for it, literally or figuratively. Despite getting it from both ends, Muslim bloggers are coming out, wanting to join the modern world and get out of the crossfire of regimes vs. extremists.

It starts with simple questions. When a Saudi girl asks why she can’t driver herself. It has big ramifications in places where people aren’t used to asking simple questions. The bloggers are the vanguard of that, asking questions that are never asked. It also breaks the govt monopoly on information, including govt-controlled press. The bottom line is that the freer the discourse is on Islam, the more modern and moderate the practices are. Muslims in America are a prime example of that. You’re free to say what you want and develop in harmony with your non-Muslim neighbords. It’s almost a linear correlation. That’s why I side of the free speech side of things, even while Muslim countries are grappling with the issue.

How can we help? We can use technology to pry the doors open from the outside. I’m hoping for the day when govts give up on filtering and battle ideas with other ideas rather than jackbooted thugs. We need to read and publicize the work of bloggers, advocating good ones and shaming bad ones. We need to reduce anarchy in the Muslim world. There’s been a rise of extremism, and it plays a role in what’s going on right now. That’s something the Muslim world needs to deal with internally. We need to advocate for persecuted bloggers and freedom in general. Not necessarily specific bloggers, since we don’t want them to seem like US puppets. But we should push for general press freedoms while leaving specific advocacy to us - the blogosphere.

Tesanovic:

I come from Serbia. In the early 90s, I was a feminist and activist for Women in Black. When the war was going on, people would ask me what was going on, so I decided to write a letter for everyone. It wasn’t journalism but more than a diary. It was a blog before they were called that, sent over mailing lists. When Serbia was bombed in ’99, I was sitting in my flat watching the international news channels, and I was seeing myself bombed on TV. But it was still information - Milosovic was lying and you couldn’t trust local news. When a southern town was bombed, I called my relatives and they saw people killed by cluster bombs. Milosovic denied it but NATO called it collateral damage and acted like it didn’t exist. So we were invisible victims. So I started writing about it online anonymously.

This went on for a couple of months, then a friend asked me if I was the one doing it. Eventually the media started asking me if it’s me. They wanted to talk with me but not identify me, since they didn’t want me to get killed by Milosovic or looters or NATO or anyone else. But I outed myself in a letter and said the public is my only protection, then told the governments, this is where I live - come and get me. I didn’t want to hide.

 

 

 

Listen to this article Listen to a computer-generated podcast of this article

Related topics:

 

 

Egyptian judge acts against Web sites
Legalbrief (subscription) - Durban,South Africa
El-Adly Video Gate
Hossam el-Hamalawy, 3arabawy - Cairo, Egypt
The ’Crime’ Of Blogging In Egypt
The Washington Post
Bloggers being watched in the Middle East.
ANNA JOHNSON, Associated Press - Cairo, Egypt

Bloggers in Mideast transforming dialogue but face clampdowns by authorities
A.P - Cairo, Egypt

More videos of Egyptian police brutality
Hossam el-Hamalawy, 3arabawy - Cairo, Egypt
Boulaq torturers to be tried 9 January
Hossam el-Hamalawy, 3arabawy - Cairo, Egypt
Partial Blacklist of Egyptian Police Officers Accused of Torture
Ikhwanweb, London-UK
Torture victim receives 3 months in prison for “resisting authorities”!
Ikhwanweb, London-UK
An interview with Ayman Al Zawahri’s uncle
Ikhwanweb, London-UK
Egyptian politics
Washington Times - Washington,DC,USA
Egyptian police torture woman detainee (Videos)
Ikhwanweb, London-UK
MB blogs: A Step Towards More Freedom of Expression
Ikhwanweb, London-UK
Blogs Against Military Rulers
Ikhwanweb, London-UK
MB blogs: A Step Towards More Freedom of Expression
Ikhwanweb, London-UK
Breaking News: 27 websites, including blogs, sued
By The Sandmonkey
Egypt: Muslim Brotherhood Bloggers
By Amira Al Hussaini
Marking 4th Anniversary of Torturing State Security Detainee No.25
Ikhwanweb, London-UK
SXSW: Blogging where speech isn’t free
By Ethan


Posted in Other Blogs , Youth , MB Blogs , MB in International press , Reform Issues , Development , Other Blogs , Youth , MB Blogs , MB in International press , Reform Issues , Development , Other Blogs , Youth , MB Blogs , MB in International press , Reform Issues , Development , Other Blogs , Youth , MB Blogs , MB in International press , Reform Issues , Development  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Egyptian Bloggers Hold Conference to Defend Freedoms
One hell of feast for the MB bloggers
Egyptian Regime Blocks Opposition Websites, Weblogs
Egyptian bloggers expose horror of police torture
Blogging consequences
Web users at internet cafes allegedly under the radar of state security, says blogger
Scenario of succession ...how Egyptian bloggers regard it
Egyptian blogger Monem threatened again
Blogging for democracy around the world
Arab Bloggers Exercise Democracy and Prompt Debate Despite Tough Opposition From Governments
Inside the belly of the dog, A blog on his birthday for Sasha
Egypt: Award-Winning Blogger Among New Arrests
The Blogger Scene in Egypt
Sharqawi blogs from prison
Sit-In to Be Staged By Bloggers in Solidarity with Nour
Blogs on the Middle East Crisis, When More Than Just Weapons Speak
State Security threatens blogger
2006, year of crackdowns on blogging
Egypt urged to free blogger
Egypt bloggers reveal new torture case
Bloggers, Kifaya and Ikhwanweb Against Torture
Bloggers being watched in the Middle East.
MB blogs: A Step Towards More Freedom of Expression
Free the Egyptian blogger! But...
USA’s favorite Arab nation jails bloggers
Egyptian Blogging on Trial
The blogger and the pharaoh
As a blogger is jailed, promises that the internet would challenge dictators have proved illusory
Blogger on Ice
Brotherhood of The Blog
URGENT: Lawsuit to be filed to block 21 Egyptian blogs
The MB in Egypt is blogging, Where Speech Isn’t Free
Bloggers and Rights Activists Against Torture Meeting
HRW to Mubarak’s regime: Investigate police torture, rape of blogger Sharqawi
Blogging for freedom
Bloggers & New Media [Part I]
Inside the school of the Egyptian blogosphere
Arabisc: Rebelling Bloggers from Syria to Tunisia
Egypt: Bloggers Arrested in Anti-Government Rally
Egypt: Arrested Bloggers Released Following Constitutional Amendment Clashes
The Changing Face of Arab Blogs
Fighting Torture with Mobile Phones and Weblogs
Egypt: Bloggers Among Egyptian Demo Detainees
Middle East bloggers click for change
EGYPT: Egyptian democracy activist blogs from cell
Updated: 3 Egyptian Bloggers Detained
Blogs & Websites Under Threat
WPS: Blogging the New Arab Public
9 Behera MBs Detained, House of MB Blogger Raided
MB Blogger Detained
Security Forces Hunting MB Blogger Abdel Moneim Mahmoud
The Police Broke into a Journalist Blogger’s Residence
Blogger Abdel Monem Mahmoud Has Been Arrested
Blogger Moneim detained
Blogger Abdul Moneim Mahmoud Jailed 15 Days
Bloggers Protest Arrests With Their Keyboards
State security raids home, detains Brotherhood blogger
Arabeyes: Egyptian Blogger Abdul Monem Mahmood Arrested
Rights groups criticize the arrest of an Egyptian blogger
What if they arrested a blogger and nobody cared?
Bloggers may be the real opposition
Egyptian blogger ordered detained for 15 days
HRW Demands Release of MB Blogger Abdel Monem Mahmoud
’Brotherhood’ Blogs In Egypt Offer View Of Young Islamists
Bloggers Celebrate President’s Birthday, Son’s Marriage, Reject Succession
Petition For Release Of Bloggers Kareem Amer And Abdul-Moneim Mahmud
Egypt Blog Rebels Silenced
Frontline Club: Politics and blogging
Jailed MB blogger and journalist among 25 hunger strikers
Ikhwanweb’s Moneim Blogs from Egyptian Prison
Bahrain in transition, from blog to street
Media Honours Blog about Ikhwan
Another 15 Days Detention To Blogger Monem
Jailed MB Blogger Monem Mahmoud Visits Critically Ill Father
Blogger of the Brotherhood
Muslim Brotherhood Girls, Blogosphere
Al Erian: MB Bloggers’ Criticism To Leaders Healthy Phenomenon
Algeria: Algerian blogger in threat of imprisonment
House Of Egyptian Blogger Raided
Monem: No To Jailing Algerian Blogger Abd El Salam Baroudy
Blogging Against Mubarak
Blogger Detained While Covering Shura Election Day
Update:Blogger Omar el-Sharqawi released
Egypt: Elections Rigging Videos, US Aid Cuts and A New Blog by Talented Movie Director
Egypt: Blogger is Released, Court Case to Block 50 Blogs, Press Attacked By Bloggers and More
Effect of Egyptian Blogs on Politics, Society
Phone threats against bloggers continue…
Egypt: Two Bloggers Arrested
Mixed Baghdad Bloggers on the White House’s Iraq progress report.
Islamic Weblogs
Egypt’s blog rebels silenced by jail
Blogger interrogated; released on bail
Monem Was Blogging Freedom
Concerns Grow Over Bloggers Quitting Due To Govt Intimidation
Bloggers, Freedom of Expression
What if they arrested a blogger and nobody cared
Arabeyes: Bahraini Blogger in Court
Call for release of blogger who reports on torture of detainees
"Keyboards" Protest At Hunting Bloggers
Blogs Against Military Rulers
Blogger Alaa Saif: Egyptian Blogosphere Under Siege
3 Egyptian Bloggers Detained
Hosni Mubarak’s regime won’t delete Egypt’s bloggers