Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
British Citizen vs. IDF Guard
British Citizen vs. IDF Guard
One would expect the Foreign Secretary to care primarily about British citizens (in Somalia) rather than foreign (Israeli) soldiers who maintain an illegal occupation and the starvation of millions (of Palestinians), notes Gilad Atzmon.
Tuesday, February 2,2010 13:52
by Gilad Atzmon Middle East Online

 The Timesreported today that the British Government is blocking a deal for Paul and Rachel Chandler's release.

The British couple were kidnapped by Somalian pirates in the Indian Ocean. Paul and Rachel may be facing a doomed fate as the British Government is blocking a deal for their release.

A company that claimed to have had a deal for the release of Paul and Rachel Chandler said it was scuppered by the British Government's refusal to negotiate with hostage-takers and said today that it demanded to be allowed to arrange their release.

In the centre of the British Government’s refusal to interfere in this saga we meet none other than David Miliband the Foreign Secretary

The Guardian reported today that Miliband insisted that “the government would not get involved in any ransom payments to secure the Chandlers' release”.


Miliband said he could not stop private individuals from pursuing a ransom deal, but it was not in Britain's interests to make concessions to hostage-takers.

On the face of it Miliband’s stand can be easily understood. The foreign secretary could argue, for instance, that negotiating with pirates or other outlaws may expose more Brits to different security risks. Yet, it is very perplexing to find out that as much as Miliband is reluctant to interfere with the release of the abducted British couple, he rushed to voice his support in favour of the release of the IDF guard Gilad Shalit. In spite of the fact that Shalit is not a British subject and was taken prisoner in a military action while serving as a guard in the biggest concentration camp known to man namely Gaza, Miliband was rather vocal in demanding his ‘immediate’ release.

One would expect the Foreign Secretary to care primarily about British citizens rather than foreign soldiers who maintain an illegal occupation and the starvation of millions.

Here is the transcription of Miliband’s emotional plea to Hamas. It is taken from a British official governmental site.

“Today is the third anniversary of the kidnapping of Gilad Shalit. Both British Ministers and the British Ambassador in Israel have had repeated contact with Gilad's family and emphasized our support for Gilad's immediate release. Last September, the Ambassador helped to deliver over 2,000 Jewish New Year cards for Gilad to the ICRC as part of a campaign organized by the UK Jewish community. I repeat the UK's call to Hamas for his immediate, unconditional, and safe release. We share the Shalit family's dismay at Hamas's refusal to allow the ICRC access to Gilad”. (British Foreign Secretary David Miliband)


It is perplexing to find out that Miliband showed far more ‘restraint’ in his support of his troubled fellow British citizens: Paul and Rachel Chandler..

Gilad Atzmon (gilad.co.uk) is an Israeli-born writer and jazz musician living in London. He had previously served in the Israeli military but he is currently an anti-racism campaigner. His latest CD is In Loving Memory of America.



tags: IOF / IOF Troops / Somalia / Shalit / Hamas / British Government / Gilad Shalit / Miliband / Jewish Community
Posted in  
Related Articles
British government curtailing freedoms: Why Islam4UK should not be banned
Zahhar: Hamas has not closed door in face of a Shalit deal
The Release of Gilad Shalit
Israeli radio: Ramallah and Washington hinder the Shalit deal
Fadwa: We have full confidence in Palestinians negotiating Shalit deal
A reading in Gilad Shalit's Video
Muzzaini: Shalit’s whereabouts only known by a few
Hamas: No change in list of prisoners to be freed in return for Shalit
Ministry of prisoners: Press reports on Shalit deal unfounded
Red Cross slammed for calling on Hamas to let Shalit be in touch with his family
Mizeini: No progress in Shalit file unless demands are met
Full speech of UK Secretary Miliband, Engage Muslim World, Building Coalitions
Miliband Calls for Fair Engagement with Islamists
European campaign: The siege lifting should not be linked to Shalit
Expert: Truce Should be Based on 1996 April Deal, Shalit Should be Handed to France
Pirates Thrive in Lawless Somalia
Peres says talks on Shalit resumed but no progress was achieved
Hamas Leader Denies Transferring Shalit File to a Foreign Agent
Al Qaradawi Urges Al-Qaeda Release Two Austrian Hostages
Al-Zahar: Hamas Won 5-Day War, Will Release Shalit if Conditions Met
Muzaini: European parties approaching Hamas over Shalit deal
MB urges release of hostages
Akef Appeals for Iraqi Kidnappers to Set Hostages Free