Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue927 2022

Last update02:07 AM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Democracy
ElBaradei not  a passing fad
ElBaradei not a passing fad
As President Hosni Mubarak recovers from gallbladder removal surgery in Germany, he's probably spending some time thinking about former IAEA director Mohamed ElBaradei.
Wednesday, March 10,2010 14:53
by Hani Sabra Foreign Policy

A day before his operation, Mubarak commented on ElBaradei's potential presidential candidacy and said that Egypt does "not need a new national hero." That's a significant statement considering that the 81-year-old president usually lets his subordinates respond to issues like this one. Mubarak's sharp comments indicate that ElBaradei's recent rhetoric has clearly unsettled him. And looking ahead, the political temperature in Egypt will get increasingly hotter between now and 2011, when presidential elections are scheduled to take place.

First, some context: As things stand now, ElBaradei actually can't run for president. He must be one of the leaders of a "recognized" political party in order to participate. When Mubarak engineered constitutional amendments in 2007, they were designed to ensure that members of "unrecognized" parties like the Muslim Brotherhood would be unable to field independent candidates in elections -- as it did with great success in the 2005 parliamentary elections. ElBaradei prefers to run as an independent, and he is wary of the baggage attached to being identified with one of the ineffectual "legal" parties. Given this, and the fact that the Egyptian authorities will almost certainly not heed ElBaradei's call for constitutional amendments that would make it easier for him to run, ElBaradei is unlikely to enter the presidential race in 2011. Even if he does join a party and somehow manages to participate, an opposition candidate stands virtually no chance of victory. Mubarak will likely run and will certainly win if he does. Meanwhile, his son Gamal will continue to raise his profile and likely take the reins when his father dies. (The longer that Mubarak lives, the less chance that aging security establishment figures like Omar Suleiman have to become president.)

Still, ElBaradei isn't just a passing fad. Mubarak can't simply imprison him a la Ayman Nour. He's a Nobel Peace Prize winner, and his mistreatment would put Egypt under a great deal of unwanted pressure and scrutiny. At the very least, ElBaradei will continue to be a thorn in the government's side. And since returning to Egypt for vacation last week, he has gone on the offensive. Despite almost certainly receiving calls from friendly ruling National Democratic Party members telling him to cool it, ElBaradei has refused to temper his statements about Egypt's calcified political system. He has met with his supporters and heavyweights like Arab League Secretary General Amr Moussa (who was previously Egypt's popular foreign minister) and continues to talk about what he perceives as Egypt's failings because of its authoritarian political system. ElBaradei will continue to be a popular force in Egyptian politics. But several thousand Facebook fans do not make him a viable presidential candidate.

Hani Sabra is a Middle East analyst at Eurasia Group. c


tags: Baradei / Mubarak / Succession / Gamal Mubarak / Constitutional Amendments / Arab League / NDP / Presidential Elections / Parliamentary Elections / Ayman Nour / Amr Mousa / National Democratic Party
Posted in Democracy , Elbaradei Campaign  
Related Articles
Why ElBaradei?
Victim of ElBaradei's support conference.
EGYPT: Mubarak aims to cool off enthusiasm for Mohamed ElBaradei
Mubarak says ElBaradei can run in 2011
Mubarak: Egypt needs no national hero and ElBaradei is free to seek presidency
ElBaradei the nucleus
The El-Baradei phenomenon
Editorial: ElBaradei and the intoxication of hope
Conflict arises in Egypt opposition over ElBaradei’s leadership, Muslim Brotherhood
ElBaradei pushes on in Egypt, gets Coptic support
How ElBaradei Can Promote Egypt's Change
ElBaradei to head national assembly for change in Egypt
ElBaradei changing the system?
Three suggestions for Dr ElBaradei
MB attend ElBaradei's fruitful meeting with opposition trends.
Egyptian opposition form coalition around ElBaradei
ElBaradei Meets Amr Moussa
ElBaradei: Egypt at bottom of international community
Egypt's representatives meet with ElBaradei
What does ElBaradei want?