Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Elbaradei Campaign
Comment: Egypt needs a democratic legacy
Comment: Egypt needs a democratic legacy
Hosni Mubarak said last week that Egypt “does not need a national hero”. The ageing Egyptian president, who is recovering in Germany from a gall bladder operation, was answering a question about Mohamed ElBaradei, a Nobel prize winner and recently retired head of the International Atomic Energy Agency
Tuesday, March 16,2010 10:06
by Heba Saleh

Hosni Mubarak said last week that Egypt “does not need a national hero”. The ageing Egyptian president, who is recovering in Germany from a gall bladder operation, was answering a question about Mohamed ElBaradei, a Nobel prize winner and recently retired head of the International Atomic Energy Agency. Mr ElBaradei returned to Egypt, the land of his birth, last month to lead a movement pushing for democratic reform.

Mr Mubarak is right. Most Egyptians do not want new heroes. In the person of Gamal Abdel Nasser, the country’s first post-independence leader, Egypt had a “hero of liberation”, and in Anwar Sadat, his successor, it had a “hero of war and peace”. Mr Mubarak, who has ruled for 29 years, is the “hero of the October war”.

There is, to be sure, a tendency among some of Mr ElBaradei’s supporters to cast him as a hero who has come to save Egypt. Others see him as the man who will deliver the coup de grâce to presumed plans in ruling circles to arrange a succession to Gamal Mubarak, the president’s son.

But Mr ElBaradei himself has been playing down the idea that he aims to become president, emphasising instead his desire to help bring about democratic reforms. These include guarantees of free and fair elections and amendments to a constitution that gives the president unlimited terms in office and places hurdles in the path of independent candidates who want to run for the top job.

The movement that has grown around Mr ElBaradei is composed mainly of young people with no party affiliation. Some 180,000 have signed up to a Facebook group to promote him as Egypt’s next president. It is hard to gauge the real political impact of this kind of cyberspace opposition.

More important is the graphic illustration that Mr ElBaradei’s return provides that a man of his stature cannot run in presidential elections unless he joins one of the now discredited legal opposition parties. New political parties can be legalised only if approved by a committee headed by the chairman of the ruling party.

The Egyptian system is thus stacked against change. It could well be that the regime and its powerful security services brush off Mr ElBaradei and his supporters. But that would be a mistake.

The level of enthusiasm he has aroused should be taken as a positive sign. Many young and educated Egyptians yearn for change and are willing to work for it. The country’s political elite, much of it in the ruling party, should take notice.

Now with a population of almost 80m, about 40 per cent of whom live below or just above the poverty line, the country needs a political system that depends less on heroes, pharaohs and their authoritarian ilk and more on accountable leaders and credible institutions.

Crucial tasks such as an overhaul of the education and public health systems, or a reduction in fuel subsidies, need to be backed by the kind of social consensus that can only be forged through politics.

But since 1952 domestic politics has been all but abolished in Egypt. Voter turnouts are often less than 30 per cent, and a common refrain is that voting makes no difference. Changes in 2007 that have abolished judicial supervision over elections can only deepen mistrust in a flawed process.

The legal opposition parties are generally recognised as ineffectual and unelectable. They operate in a system where everyone understands that their function is to complete a democratic façade. As such they are unable to recruit members, enthuse supporters or present themselves as alternatives.

The only real opposition, the Muslim Brotherhood, remains illegal, its members and leaders a permanent target for harassment, arrest and military trials.

As he contemplates his final years in office, Mr Mubarak, who is 81, should turn his attention to the political reforms the country needs. An amended constitution that lays the basis for an inclusive, credible and competitive political system could be his most lasting legacy.

tags: Mubarak / ElBaradei / Sadat / Gamal Mubarak / Egyptian Election / Mubarak Regime / Military Tribunals / Military Courts / MB Prisoners / Abdel Nasser / October war / Poverty in Egypt / Egyptian Education / Military Tribunals / Democracy in Egypt
Posted in Elbaradei Campaign , Democracy  
Related Articles
Why ElBaradei?
Egypt President Mubarak well, rumors just that
Egypt investigates ElBaradei's beaten supporter
The return of Mohamed ElBaradei from abroad is rattling Egypt’s rulers
ElBaradei not a passing fad
FACTBOX-Who could lead Egypt after President Mubarak?
Egypt's Mubarak: three decades of rigid rule
EGYPT: Mubarak aims to cool off enthusiasm for Mohamed ElBaradei
Egypt: three decades of Mubarak's rigid rule
Mubarak undergoes simple procedure
Mubarak says ElBaradei can run in 2011
Mubarak: Egypt needs no national hero and ElBaradei is free to seek presidency
ElBaradei the nucleus
ElBaradei pushes on in Egypt, gets Coptic support
Three suggestions for Dr ElBaradei
MB attend ElBaradei's fruitful meeting with opposition trends.
Egyptian opposition form coalition around ElBaradei
Mubarak’s Zionized Regime
Egypt: ElBaradei more popular than President Mubarak
Life after Mubarak's iron rule: Egypt faces uncertain future
Mubarak’s Intervention Ends Two Year Ordeal for Egyptian Doctors
MB and Kifaya denounce Regimes' exploitation of media as propaganda for Gamal Mubarak
Gamal Mubarak: Egypt’s Next Unelected President
Activists petition against Gamal Mubarak.
IN FOCUS: Mubarak Regime and Brotherhood: Zero-Sum Game
Farwana: IOA might liquidate Sadat
Jihan El-Sadat: My Husband Was A MB Affiliate
Sadat’s widow: My Husabnd was member of the MB
Egypt’s Gamal Mubarak Aims to Underpin Growth
Gamal Mubarak Visits DC
Widespread anger in Egypt at Mubarak regime
Rights Report Criticizes MB Military Tribunals and Municipal Elections Detentions
US expresses concerns over Egyptian elections
Violette Daguerre: MB Military Tribunals are False& Unreal Political Tribunals
The 2005 Egyptian Elections: How Free? How Important?
Egyptian election campaign heats up
The American Ambassador Follows the Egyptian Elections.
The Margins of the Egyptian Elections
Egyptian elections marred by arrests, voting disruption
Islamist Opposition Parties Gaining in Egyptian Elections
3 killed in violence during Egyptian election
Gamal Mubarak: No Deals between the MB and NDP
Egypt: Mubarak Regime Cracks Down on Opposition
Gamal Mubarak Denies Egypt Reneging on Reform
Egypt: The Gamal Mubarak Paradox
Gamal Mubarak Speaks of Egypt’s Right To Nuclear Energy
The MB And Sadat 1981
Military Tribunals for MB activists!!
Egypt: Strike wave shakes Mubarak regime
Critics sharp after charges of rigging in Egyptian elections
Brotherhood, Independent MPs Reject Expelling Anwar Sadat