Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Reform Issues
A dream deferred?
A dream deferred?
MOHAMED ELBARADEI's return to Egypt in February was greeted with wild enthusiasm in Egypt's independent press, which was swift to pin long-held hopes for reform on the former chief of the IAEA, and near silence from the state media where Mr ElBaradei was pilloried in December.
Wednesday, July 21,2010 20:45
by by The Economist online Economist

Less than six months on, however, and the opinion columns look somewhat different. Writers for Egypt's leading independent publications have started to show signs of frustration at the limited impact  of Mr ElBaradei's campaign, and criticisms of his approach are increasingly frequent. Mohamed Esmat, writing in independent daily al-Shorouk, suggests that the Nobel prize winner might even be harming Egypt's chances for reform:

Mr ElBaradei fails to recognise that his current requests for reform were made by dozens of political parties, whether publicly or secretly, decades ago. Mr ElBaradei also fails to acknowledge that Egyptians were hoping that he would run for presidency through an opposition party. The National Democratic Party's obstinate rules will not change before the next presidential elections. Finally, Mr ElBaradei does not realise that by stealing the spotlight from other potential candidates, change in Egypt has become less likely. 

Similarly, in al-Masri al-Youm, a popular independent daily, Mohsen Abdel Rahman chastised the would-be reformer for spending too much time criticising the current system and not enough developing his own initiatives:

I have often heard Mr ElBaradei, in both his own statements and interviews with Hassan Nafaa [a leading reform campaigner], complain about a lack of support and that he has nowhere to make his headquarters to officially launch his campaign or the activities of his National Association for Change. A man’s capital is his brain, followed by his thought process. I don’t believe that Messrs ElBaradei and Nafaa are lacking in thought or creativity, but constant moaning always hinders productive thinking and creativity. 

Mr ElBaradei faces criticism elsewhere too. In Kuwait, which deported 17 of Mr ElBaradei's supporters in April, al-Watan newspaper published a stinging denunciation of a leader who, writer Fouad al-Hasim considers, is a symbol of Western interference in the region:

To be quite honest, I’m growing tired of Mohamed ElBaradei’s statements and pictures in the media. I now only see Karzai—Afghanistan’s ruler—without the hat and with an Egyptian accent! Mr ElBaradei—who is known to be a man of the West and specifically of the US—has come to Egypt from Austria carrying “perfume and disinfectants” so he can “sanitize” Egypt’s roads from Alexandria to Aswan. 

Back in Egypt, Mokhtar Noah in al-Dustur, an independent daily known for its sharp criticism of Hosni Mubarak's regime, describes sarcastically a utopian dream he had after watching news clips of Mr ElBaradei and his supporters. The implication is clear: only in people's dreams will Mr ElBaradei ever become president of Egypt:

In spite of a lack of support, Mr ElBaradei is doing just fine. He has become the great white hope of the Egyptian public and is more popular than anyone had ever expected. I am following his movements closely on all the satellite channels (the international ones of course). While I was watching a clip of Mr ElBaradei and the public rallying around him, I fell asleep.  I fell into a deep slumber. In my dreams, I saw that God had blessed us! Mr ElBaradei became the president of the Arab Republic of Egypt.

Farouk Goweida, an Egyptian poet, also talks of dreams in al-Shorouk, reflecting on a democratic ideal made impossible by the current regime. Perhaps more encouragingly for Mr ElBaradei, Mr Goweida closes on a note of determination:

Egyptians will always cling to an old dream: one day to have free elections, committees without fraud, a parliament that reflects the popular will, and political choices made by the people. This dream will never be achieved while National Democratic Party retains its grip on politics and while it maintains a majority in parliament and the Shura Council by law or by fraud...But still, we won't give up our dreams of a future in which we see free and fair elections.

For further commentary from the Arab press, go to Meedan.net.


tags: IAEA / ElBaradei / Reform / National Democratic Party / Political Parties
Posted in Reform Issues  
Related Articles
MB in Alexandria postpones Reform Conference for Khaled Saeed
21, 000 signatures on MB petition supporting ElBaradei's demand for reform
A Talk with Iran's Dawa and Reform Group SecGen Abdulrahman Mohammad Birani
MB reform demand petition gathers 16, 000 signatures to date
Reform tops MB Chairman's meeting with NAC coordinator
MB launches nationwide petition in support of ElBaradei's call for reform
MB and NAC cooperate for political reform
MB and ElBaradei agree on reform
8 Egyptians detained over Democratic Reform pledge
MB chairman meets with Ghad Party leader to discuss political reform
Lawyer pushes for jail reform in Egypt
Islamic Reform conference defining moment in Western Muslim History
Police clash with activists as opposition unite with MB call for reform
Egypt: sweeping reform needed to protect workers’ rights
More Than Good Intentions Needed to Reform Libya
Change and reform bloc appreciates Larijani's stand
MB chairman: MB support Dr.Baradei's call for Political Reform
ElBaradei's political reform campaign continues rounds on the road
Morsy: The MB will continue their plea for reform and welcome all who wish to support the call
Muslims Today: A Radical Reform