Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Elbaradei Campaign
Commentary: The boycott blunder
Commentary: The boycott blunder
Egypt has been governed for 29 years by President Hosni Mubarak, and a state of emergency limiting civil liberties has been in effect for that entire time.
Wednesday, September 15,2010 07:19
Mc Clatchydc.com

 Egypt has been governed for 29 years by President Hosni Mubarak, and a state of emergency limiting civil liberties has been in effect for that entire time. The most popular opposition party, the Muslim Brotherhood, is banned and its candidates must run as independents. Egyptian political analysts expect that the government will manipulate this fall's parliamentary elections, as it has in the past, to guarantee the ruling National Democratic Party another sweeping majority.

Against this backdrop, Nobel Peace Prize laureate and opposition leader Mohamed ElBaradei has called for a boycott of the elections unless electoral reforms are implemented first. "If nobody but the national party runs, then the regime will have to give in to us," ElBaradei said. A boycott, he added on Twitter, would "unmask sham 'democracy.' Participation wld. be contrary to the national will."

With that, ElBaradei has stepped into a longstanding debate about whether participating in unfair elections allows opposition groups to push the boundaries of freedom, or whether it simply legitimizes undemocratic regimes by offering the appearance of pluralism. Egypt is hardly alone in pondering this dilemma. Iraq's Sunni parties boycotted the U.S.-backed parliamentary elections in January 2005, then decided they had made a strategic blunder and participated in subsequent votes. Earlier this year, Burundi's main opposition parties boycotted a presidential election over allegations of massive fraud, delivering a second five-year term to the unopposed incumbent, President Pierre Nkurunziza. Around the globe in Myanmar, also known as Burma, the military junta that has governed for 20 years is scheduled to hold its first parliamentary elections on Nov. 7 amid charges of foul play. Nobel Peace Prize laureate Aung San Suu Kyi is barred from running and her party is boycotting, although a splinter group has decided to run.

A true democratic process depends on the participation of its citizens. The question for opposition movements in these countries and many others is whether it's possible to build democracy by withholding citizen participation. The argument of those supporting a boycott in Egypt is that they have tried taking part in electoral politics for decades but have failed to pry open the system; they see a boycott as a kind of last resort, or "the least bad option available." Some Burmese activists make the opposite argument in Myanmar: that two decades of boycotts have not loosened the military's grip on power and that participation may prove more effective.

In fact, a closer look at scores of election boycotts in recent decades suggests that they rarely lead to democratization. Rather, parties that choose to sit out the elections usually are weakened, while rulers are returned to office with greater majorities in the legislature and with more entrenched power. Participation by opposition parties, on the other hand, can sometimes lead to dramatic results, as it did in the Philippines, where President Corazon Aquino's "people power" revolution toppled strongman Ferdinand Marcos in 1986, or in the so-called color revolutions of Eastern Europe in the early 2000s. In these cases, authoritarian regimes were dislodged by massive street demonstrations protesting stolen elections.

Of course, that's not necessarily the outcome. The Iranian reform movement fielded a candidate in last year's presidential election but lost to incumbent President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and took to the streets to protest fraud. The largest demonstrations in 30 years of Islamic rule were brutally quashed and the opposition has been suppressed, yet many reformists believe the vote was valuable for exposing political dissent and government thuggery to the world.

Some elections experts argue that although boycotts don't generally work, the serious threat of a boycott can sometimes force a government to even the playing field, and that may be ElBaradei's calculation in Egypt. His National Front for Change has collected more than 700,000 signatures on its petition for electoral reform, thanks to help from the Muslim Brotherhood. ElBaradei, a secular Muslim and former head of the International Atomic Energy Agency, has international stature; it would be difficult for the government to jail him, as it did human rights activist and liberal El Ghad party leader Ayman Nour for four years. It's good that ElBaradei is using his prestige to push or, if necessary, try to embarrass Mubarak into holding free and fair elections.

That said, actually boycotting the election would be a mistake. The opposition is divided; the Muslim Brotherhood, whose "independent" members currently hold about a fifth of the seats in parliament, has not signed on to a boycott (and certainly, a partial boycott never works). But beyond that, parliamentary elections are a time to build grass-roots support. ElBaradei would do better to draw Egyptians out of a state of political apathy and resignation, and to help elect opposition members to parliament, where they would have a higher profile and some immunity to push for more reforms. He needs to grow his own political base and boost his street credibility if he wants to run for president in next year's election, as has been suggested, and that is best done through organizing. If the elections are stolen, he and the rest of the opposition should use their collective voice to protest.

This is a pivotal moment in Egyptian politics. At age 82, Mubarak may be mulling a sixth six-year term - he hasn't said - or he may be hoping to hand power to his son. Either way, he isn't going to be in power for long, and succession is not guaranteed. The parliamentary elections are an opportunity to prepare the ground for next year's crucial contests. The opposition should participate - not boycott.

Read more:
tags: Mubarak / Emergency Law / Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood / Democracy in Egypt / Ahmadinejad / Ayman Nour / Gamal Mubarak / NDP / Ruling Regime / Inheritance / ElBaradei / NAC / Egyptian Opposition / Presidential Election / Egyptian Elections / Political Reform / Moderate Muslim Brotherhood / Moderate MB / Egyptian Constitution / Article 76 / IAEA / Miscs / baradei picture daughter / baradei private pictures facebook / baradi daughter photos facebook / baradi's daughter picture / cache:abqvh8dv5wsj:www.lifedork.net/look-at-private-pictures-on-facebook.html leila baradei / como hacer wall photos facebook / download baradei daughter pic / el baradi daughter pictures on facebook / elbaradei daughter pic / elbaradei laila photo / elbaradei laila secret / Facebook / facebook at / facebook exploits / facebook how to view private photo / facebook leila baradei / facebook private album javascript / facebook private fotos hacken / facebook private javascript / facebook private photos / facebook private pics / facebook private pics legitimate / facebook private pictures / facebook private profile hack / facebook private wall javascript / facebook see photos / facebook see private album javascript / facebook see private photos / facebook show hack hidden albums / facebook view hidden albums / facebook view private photos javascript / facebook view private pics javascript / fotos de laila baradei / greasemonkey hidden facebook profile / hace hidden album in facebook / hidden facebook photos javascript new / how can you see photos on private page on facebook / how do you look at private pictures on facebook / how do you view private pictures on facebook / how to look at private facebook pictures / how to look at private facebook profiles / how to look at private pictures on facebook / how to look for private pix in facebook / how to see blocked pictures on facebook / how to see facebook private pictures / how to see locked photos on facebook / how to see private facebook albums / how to see private facebook pictures / how to see private facebook pix / how to see private photos facebook / how to see private photos on facebook / how to see private pictures / how to see private pictures in facebook / how to see private pictures on facebook / how to view facebook pictures / how to view facebook private photos / how to view people private facebook pictures / how to view private facebook account pictures / how to view private facebook photos / how to view private facebook photos javascript / how to view private facebook pictures / how to view private facebook profiles / how to view private photo in facebook / how to view private picture real / how to view private pictures on facebook / how to view private profile pictures in facebook / java script facebook foto private / javascript facebook private photos / javascript facebook view hidden pictures / javascript to see private walls on facebook / javascript view private facebook wall / laila el baradei s friend who published pictures / laila elbaradei / laïla elbaradei facebook / laila elbaradei pic / laila elbaradei pictures / laila elbaradei pix / laila elbaradei private pic / laila elbaradei rumour / layla baradei / layla baradi bikini / leila baradei photos / look / look at private facebook / looking at private pictures in facebook / looking facebook private photos / matildas pictures facebook / navigate private pictures facebook / on / on at look / only friends facebook photo see hack / photo leila baradi / photos for baradei daughter / PICTURES / pictures of laila elbaradei / pictures private / private albums facebook / private facebook photos / private facebook photos javascript / private facebook pictures / private photos facebook / private photos of elbaradei’s family / private picture on facebook / private pictures facebook / secrets of elbaradei family leila photo / see blocked pictures on facebook / see facebook photos / see pictures facebook / see private facebook pictures / see private picture facebook / see private pictures / see private pictures on facebook / seeing private pictures on facebook / show facebook private pictures of leila elbaradei / there is no way to view facebook private photos / utube baradei daughter pictures / v tünel / view a private facebook profile / view facebook photos / view facebook private photos / view facebook private picture / view facebook private pictures / view facebook private profile / view facebook private wall photos / view facebook wall on private / view hidden albums on fb / view photos of laila el baradei facebook / view private facebook javascript / view private facebook photo album / view private facebook photos / view private facebook photos javascript / view private facebook pictures / view private myspace pictures 2010 / view private photos on facebook / view private pictures facebook / view private pictures facebook hack / view private pictures in facebook / viewing private pictures on facebook / youtube layla al baradei
Posted in Elbaradei Campaign , Democracy  
Related Articles
Egypt: Security detains activist involved in ElBaradei campaign
NDP parliamentary nominations postponed to end of month
ElBaradei warns of looming civil disobedience
Coptic Solidarity calls on Mubarak to make peace in his country first
Gamal Mubarak’s non-campaign
Carnegie Endowment: Mubarak seeks US support for the presidency
NAC representative calls for a unified stance on elections
NDP will nominate president Mubarak for 6th term
MB opinion: Ruling regime should work on solving power crisis rather than defaming MB
Egyptian opposition: Regime has reached lowest level of behaviour
Gamal Mubarak’s banners destroyed
MB and NAC hold press conference slamming arrests of reform petitioners
Why Not Boycott? The Egyptian Opposition and the November Elections
Mubarak avoids addressing presidential election issue
Interview with Mohamed ElBaradei on Democracy in Egypt
Egyptians unite in silent protest against police brutality and emergency law
Egyptian PM: Emergency law necessary for Egypt 's prosperity
Al-Erian: MB’s visit with Ghad Party has nothing to do with supporting Ayman Nour in presidential elections
Ruling regime defies parole release for MB detainees
The Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood: Islamist Participation in a Closing Political Environment
Activists against Inheritance condemns the arrest of MB
Moussavi: Suppressing students won't save Ahmadinejad - Summary
MB and Kifaya denounce Regimes' exploitation of media as propaganda for Gamal Mubarak
MB joins drive against presidential "inheritance"
Muslim Brotherhood MP's to attend conference organized by Ayman Nour
NDP Prepares for Presidential Elections Amid Muslim Brotherhood Crackdown
Iran’s Presidential Debates: Ahmadinejad vs. Mousavi
Power-inheritance, fatwa and Legitimacy in egypt
Egyptian elections: Brotherhood says it’s ready
Arrest of Muslim Brotherhood supporters illustrates limits to democracy in Egypt
The Draft Party Platform of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood:
The 2005 Egyptian Elections: How Free? How Important?