Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue927 2022

Last update02:07 AM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Arab Revolutions > EGYPT
Egypt’s Blood, America’s Complicity
Egypt’s Blood, America’s Complicity
FOR millions of Egyptians still reeling from the shock of Wednesday’s state-led massacre, which killed at least 600 peaceful protesters and possibly many more, the questions are now very basic: How do you reconcile with people who are prepared to kill you, and how do you stop them from killing again?
Friday, August 16,2013 08:53
by Dr. Amr Darrag NyTimes.Com

CAIRO — FOR millions of Egyptians still reeling from the shock of Wednesday’s state-led massacre, which killed at least 600 peaceful protesters and possibly many more, the questions are now very basic: How do you reconcile with people who are prepared to kill you, and how do you stop them from killing again?


I represent an alliance of Egyptians who oppose the military coup that overthrew President Mohamed Morsi in July. Over the last two weeks, we have met with foreign diplomats, including Bernardino León, the European Union envoy, and William J. Burns, the American deputy secretary of state, who were invited by the coup’s leaders to mediate. We respectfully listened, honestly communicated our assessment of the situation and emphasized our desire to find a peaceful solution.


But those efforts were doomed by the bad faith of Gen. Abdul-Fattah el-Sisi, Egypt’s military ruler. It was he, not the alliance, who rejected the mediators’ proposals.


The mediation efforts have been problematic. Diplomats and journalists continue to speak about negotiating only with the Muslim Brotherhood, even though the protesters come from all over the political spectrum; 69 percent of the country opposed the coup, one Egyptian poll showed.


Worse, shocking and irresponsible rhetoric from the State Department in Washington and from other Western diplomats — calling on the Brotherhood and demonstrators to “renounce” or “avoid” violence (even when also condemning the state’s violence) — has given the junta cover to perpetrate heinous crimes in the name of “confronting” violence. The protest sites have been teeming with foreign correspondents for the last several weeks, and there has not been a shred of evidence suggesting the presence of weapons, or of violence initiated by protesters.


The mediators’ most disastrous error was their choice to put pressure on the victims. In their eyes, we were the cause of the crisis, not the illegal putsch that suspended the Constitution and kidnapped the president.


Secretary of State John Kerry’s astonishing remark on Aug. 1 that the coup was “restoring democracy,” despite a disavowal from the White House, did not leave the impression that America was on the side of the peaceful protesters.


If only we could accept the coup as a fait accompli, we were told, all would be well. There would be “good will gestures” from the military, and there would be an “inclusive” democracy.


We have heard all those promises before. The military and so-called liberal elites have shown time and again that they believe they are entitled to a veto over Egyptians’ choices. But the general who betrayed his oath and held the only elected president in the history of Egypt in extralegal detention cannot be trusted to let an opposition movement survive, let alone thrive.


For those seriously interested in a way out of this crisis, some hard facts must be acknowledged.


First, this is a battle between those who envision a democratic, pluralistic Egypt in which the individual has dignity and power changes hands at the ballot box and those who support a militarized state in which government is imposed on the people by force.


Second, this coup has already sent Egypt back into the dark ages of dictatorship — with tight military control over both state-owned and private media, attacks on peaceful protesters and journalists, and detention of opposition leaders without criminal charges or due process.


Third, there is no promise that General Sisi can make that he hasn’t already betrayed. He took an oath to uphold the Constitution; he suspended the Constitution. He took an oath to loyally serve in the government; he toppled that government. And in the classic doublespeak of military juntas, he loudly condemned the opposition for dealing with foreign powers, while he was actively seeking the help of Western diplomats as well as the Persian Gulf sheikdoms that largely financed his coup.


Read The Rest Of Article on nytimes

tags: Coup / Anti-Coup / Pro-Democracy / Morsi / Rabaa / Egyptian People / Revolution / January 25 / Peaceful Protests / Massacre / Egyptian Military / Military Coup / Rabaa Al-Adaweya
Posted in EGYPT  
Related Articles
Anti-Coup Alliance Statement: Major Massacre During Crackdown Against Rabaa and Nahda Sit-Ins
Anti-Coup Alliance Statement: Signs of Coup Failure, Harbingers of Victory Against Putschists
Anti-Coup Alliance Statement Affirms No Invitation to Dialogue Received
Anti-Coup Alliance Statement on Comments by Amnesty International MENA Deputy Director
Anti-Coup National Alliance Statement on Victory Day Million-Man Marches
Anti-Coup Alliance Statement Condemns Israeli Drone Operation Inside Egyptian Borders
Anti-Coup Alliance Statement on Celebration Of ‘Victory Day’
Anti-Coup Alliance Response to Military-Installed Putschist Presidency Statement
Anti-Coup Alliance Statement on Eid Al-Fitr and Steadfastness Until Victory
Statement from the ‘Media Professors Against the Coup Front’
Anti-Coup Alliance Statement on National and International Initiatives to End Egypt Crisis
Development is Freedom: Statement by Economists Against the Coup
Egypt Anti-Coup, Pro-Democracy National Alliance: Our Peacefulness is Our Strength
Anti-Coup Alliance, Muslim Brotherhood: Denying Karman Egypt Entry is Police State Practice
Anti-Coup Alliance Statement on US Delegation Meet Saturday, August 3
Anti-Coup Alliance Statement Condemns Security Forces Attack on Friday August 2 Protesters
Statement by the Anti-Coup Pro-Democracy Alliance Regarding Today's Events at the Media Production City
Statement by the Human Rights Committee at the Anti-Coup Alliance on the Regime's Violation of Freedom of Assembly
Anti-Coup Pro-Democracy Alliance Announces New Sit-In and Protests Locations
List of Live Streaming Links of Current Anti-Coup Protests